The Rubio Consensus on Immigration and National Identity
Peter Laffin, Washington Examiner, November 16, 2026
{snip}
That shift in principle has begun to translate into an emerging policy consensus: that America should keep welcoming newcomers, but more selectively, and only on the condition that they embrace both the creed and the culture. That means fidelity to the Constitution and the Declaration, as well as to English, our civic habits, and the shared history that made those principles possible.
Like any workable consensus, it doesn’t satisfy everyone. But it keeps a large enough share of the Right’s coalition intact while speaking to independent voters who have soured significantly on the Trump administration’s handling of immigration.
The one thing that consensus needed was a prominent voice. It found one last week in Secretary of State Marco Rubio, the son of Cuban immigrants, who captured its essence in remarks to the Federalist Society (emphasis added):
“Some of the most patriotic people you’ll ever meet are people that are Americans by choice, not people that are Americans — and I’ll tell you why.”
“I’ve lived in America my entire life. I was born in the United States. I’ve grown up here.… But when you meet someone who knows what life is like somewhere else, when you meet someone that knows what it’s like to live in a society where you don’t have — not just political freedoms, but where your very future is determined on the day you are born, by what your parents did and whether they were connected or not — when you meet people like that, they know that life in this country is special. They know that life in this country is different. And they have a lot to contribute.
“So Americans by choice — people that did it the right way and chose to be Americans — oftentimes, I think, understand how special this country is more than someone like me, even, who was born here and lived their entire life and have never had to live under a different system.”
{snip}
Rubio’s remarks do three things: 1) they stress that Americans can be made, not just born, a crucial distinction that walls off bigots such as failed candidate for Texas Railroad Commissioner Bo French, who claims a greater stake in America because he is white and his family arrived here 400 years ago; 2) they offer common ground between conservatives and the moderates needed to win elections; and just as important, 3) they define “Americans by choice” as people who “did it the right way,” whose claim on America begins with respect for the nation’s ideals, laws, and cultural heritage.
{snip}













