Posted on July 8, 2026
Karmelo Anthony Fighting for New Trial, New Judge
TMZ Staff, TMZ, July 7, 2026
{snip}
The defense filed two major motions Tuesday — one seeking to remove Judge John Roach from all remaining post-trial proceedings, and another asking the court to throw out Anthony’s conviction altogether. Anthony’s lawyers argue the new-trial issues should be decided by a different judge and want Judge Roach to recuse himself.
{snip}
The separate motion for a new trial claims Anthony’s constitutional rights were violated … arguing courtroom access restrictions deprived him of a public trial and prosecutors backed away from an off-the-record agreement that ultimately led Anthony not to testify in his own defense.
{snip}













