A 63-year-old war veteran was attacked and stabbed by a group of young girls on a subway after he rebuked them for being too noisy.

The group of girls – who were thought to be drunk – were aged between 15 and 20 and were traveling on a New York subway early on Sunday morning.

Ralph Carnegary, of Queens, said he was on his way to work as a souvenir vendor on Wall Street when he encountered the gang around 6.15am.

He told the New York Daily News he ‘couldn’t hear himself think’ and made a remark to his friend about them being ‘retarded’ if they felt the need to talk so loudly.

When he told the group to calm down and be quiet, that’s when they turned on him, a witness said.

The eight girls started punching Mr Carnegary with their fists. He was trying to shield himself and block their punches when one of them allegedly yelled: ‘Go for him’ and ‘cut him’.

It was then that one of them stabbed the veteran in the shoulder – which required treatment of seven stitches in hospital.

He told the Daily News: ‘I didn’t think they were actually going to knife me. The oldest one didn’t look no more than 18 or 19. I couldn’t believe they did that.’

Police arrested Shanice Brown, 20, Kimberly Molina, 20, Starmeik Driggins, 19, and Sheyla Figueroa, 18, all from Brooklyn.

Also Martha Bermudez and Sha-steva Burdos both 17 and from Queens, and Michelle Rodriguez, 19, of the Bronx.

A 15-year-old girl from Queens was also arrested, but her name was not released because she is a juvenile.

A city bus driver who witnessed their arrest told the New York Post that the women, beers in hand, were yelling: ‘We didn’t do anything!’ as they were being cuffed.

A knife was recovered at the scene. All are charged with gang assault, assault, menacing, rioting, criminal possession of a weapon and disorderly conduct.


Share This

We welcome comments that add information or perspective, and we encourage polite debate. If you log in with a social media account, your comment should appear immediately. If you prefer to remain anonymous, you may comment as a guest, using a name and an e-mail address of convenience. Your comment will be moderated.
  • Church_of_Jed

    In his book called White Flight, Krause blames Whites for “abandoning the public space,” but he never mentions the innate tendency of afrovoodoo black Diversity for turning the public space into Whitey Endangerment Zones.

    • SouthernWhite

      Hey man, what is the authors full name who wrote that book  WHITE FLIGHT??

      • Guest


      • Church_of_Jed

        Kevin M. Kruse

    • potato78

       common sense. dark skin hybrid people usually are very loud people. you should stay away from them.

      • HenryHolliday

        If public transportation is what you’re stuck with, you don’t have much choice. I know quite a few people in that situation. I’ve ridden with them a few times, but I’m legally armed to the teeth, lethal and nonlethal. It’s generally a dicey situation for one or two white people, especially at night. I rode once alone, and once with another sheepdog. It was still very tense, never less than five to one odds, usually more. I guess we didn’t look vulnerable enough.

      • Church_of_Jed

        Stop insulting people with comparing them to the dark skin mongrels.

  • MekongDelta69

    This is a normal day on the subways here.

    But damn – don’t they look attractive?!!! Hahahahahaha

  • JackKrak

    I’m sure they’re devestated now that their shot at Harvard Law is gone….

    • MekongDelta69

      Sadly – they’ll probably be the first ones admitted.

    • Church_of_Jed

      Wrong- they’ll get admitted based on Diversity that overcame life’s challenges.

      • dukem1

        In particular, the challenges of the criminal justice system…
        Tho’ to be fair, from the looks of them, asking them to turn it down a notch would be like asking them to fly.
        Just no can do.

      • Ian


    • ljot2

      They can still contribute as doctors, nurses, and hospital security directors under Obamacare.

      • vladdy1

        More than you know. That bill includes lots of quotas, only giving our tax money to institutions with the right numbers of blacks. We’re doomed.

    • Hardly…they now have that diverse life experience so prized by Harvard when considering minority applicants.

    • They can score a 25%/100% on the FDNY exam and become firefighters….

  • Biff_Maliboo

    ” Sha-steva.”

    More reckless use of punctuation by a group that never created a written language. Vote for me and I’ll take all their apostrophes away.

    So, is that pronounced “Shawsteevah” or “Shawdashsteevah?”

    ’cause you know the dash don’t be silent.

    • MekongDelta69

      Well, Sha’steva was already taken by one of her homie’s Moms, so ya just’ gotsa tah go wit’ watchu gots left. Nahmeen?

      • The Worlds Scapegoat

         I could barely understand what you wrote. It must take great intelligence for those Afro-can’ts  to communicate with such a language.

    • Church_of_Jed

      I UnDo my White privilege by emancipating the Diversity from the White man’s English language. 

  • It seems an absurdity to describe these nasty characters as “women”. They appear to be a group  of black lesbians. With the testosterone surging thru their veins they were spoling to hurt somebody. Our rotten stinking legal system will heap penalties for politically incorrect crimes,but these brutish pigs will get a slap on the wrist.

    • Church_of_Jed

      Your comment is offensive.

      Stop insulting brutish pigs by comparing them to these feral afrovoodoos.

    • IstvanIN

       So non-lesbian females of color would behave any differently?  Dainty little flowers of femininity females of color usually are!

  • Francis Galton

    Hey, if you have a “Death Wish,” intentionally demand that a noisy group of blacks be quiet (knowing full well what will happen), and then be thoroughly prepared to defend yourself.  That is all….

    • dukem1

       Or be prepared to die…NYC…what a dump…If only they had been breastfed as infants.

  • ljot2

    The victim prudently refrained from doing a Goetz or a Zimmerman on the youths, saving himself from a jailterm, if not a lynchmob.

  • The__Bobster

    I’ve yet to see a photo of Ralph Carnegary.

    Hell, it took a while for the MSM to list the names of these fine, cultured ladies.

    BTW, John Rocker was right!

  • tickyul

    I do not want to cast stones at the victim. BUT, I have lived around scum all of my life…..when they act stupid and/or threatening…..do not confront them……just leave the area ASAP.

  • Disgusting! This is what diversity brings to your life! They should have been charged with attempted murder! I have to believe this sort of thing would have been rare when public lynchings were the norm.

  •  NAMs (no-Asian minorities), acting like they own the place (e.g., exercising dominance over everyone else). How typical….

    Free Crime Avoidance & Self-Defense Advice here:

    • Pandemonium

      For now, they pretty much do “own the place”. 

      How many of us refrain from going to certain places because of “them”. They own all of those places we do not go to. This would include most of the “inner cities” throughout this country. And much more.

      They “own” so much of the public transit. They own many of the city parks, pools, basketball courts, etc.

      We have given up way to much. Time to start taking it back. Time to start putting pressure on the politicians. 

      I just got a call from a “Romney tele-caller” dude. He asked for money. I asked him what was Romney’s stance on Affirmative Action. He said he was sure Romney supported it. I said “not one thin dime, then. AA is simply racial discrimination….against Whites”. He was flabbergasted. 

      The big kicker…..he “sounded” like a black. Yeah, I know… that’s raciss of me to say I can tell from the sound of their voice…but I can.

  • bluffcreek1967

    Exactly! If one of these feral Black females attacks you, deal with her as you would a fully-grown man! I’ve seen how these ghetto ‘sistas’ fight, and they are brutal. The only sensible response if they attack you is to be even more brutal to them!

  • The Worlds Scapegoat

    Drunk on a Sunday morning?

    They must have been going to church. A black church.


  • The Worlds Scapegoat

    colored or collared?

    As in tracking collar for convicts.

  • HenryHolliday

    Here’s a bit of practical advice, based on anecdotes I’ve heard. I guess this is what we might call First Steps
     If you do decide to confront a group of blacks over extremely obnoxious behaviour, or defend yourself  against 10 against one verbal abuse,  (physical assault is a different matter entirely)  carefully pick the time and place to make a stand.  The person who described this to me stressed that they pick their circumstances very carefully. Have as many allies on the conveyance as possible, but sit apart so they won’t associate you with one another. If the blacks behave in such a way that some response is appropriate, one of you politely initiates the discussion. When they start screaming and threatening, your allies all turn and face them with baleful looks on their faces. I know this to have worked very effectively several times, and so far no violence has come of it. The thugs are so taken aback at being confronted by numbers and determination, they are cowed. They are totally unaccustomed to it.Just a bit of residual muttering. Needless to say. all of your party need to be willing and able to physically defend themselves if necessary. But so far, it hasn’t been. The idea behind this is to weaken the idea that whites won’t come to the defense of other whites when they see them attacked, a problem that has long plagued us.

    • Up to my neck in CA

      Just make sure you know the Whites that will back you up. The ones you don’t will run away like scared babies leaving you 12 vs 1.

      • HenryHolliday

        They choose their members very carefully indeed.

  • It’s a nightmare being in a confined space with minorities. They sit and stand at a distance from each other and shout their conversations.

    As a metro rider, I sympathize with this man. It takes great restaint to not confront these miscreants. They’re just itching for someone to say something. 

    While riding the bus and train, I often ask myself, “Whether ’tis Nobler in the mind to sufferThe Slings and Arrows of outrageous Fortune, Or to take Arms against a Sea of troubles,And by opposing end them”.

    • Pandemonium

      Always carry Bear-guard at the very least. 

    • Up to my neck in CA

      They love to be make spectacles of themselves and crave attention, even negative attention. The have no manners or respect of others.

  • Just look at other photos…..what an ugly parade. 

  • Pandemonium

    Exactly! Tell me why stabbing someone in the chest is NOT attempted murder???

  • Eurobeing

    From the photo it looks like one of those girls might be a white wanna be a nigga. She has her shirt pulle up and you can see her waist.

    I wonder what her home life is like? Bet she comes from a broken home.

  • That disgusting smirk on the girl being led by the police.  Most white people have the dignity to frown.

  • joewest666

    Dey didn’t dew nuffins..

    Can we line em up against the wall and shoot them yet?

  • The__Bobster

    Wait! It gets better.


    Starmeik Driggins, held in subway attack on Vietnam vet, was protecting her lover, lawyer says
    Teen claims Ralph Carnegary punched her in face when she tried to help girlfriend Sheila Figeroa

    THE WOMAN accused of slashing a Vietnam vet on the subway says she was protecting her lover.Starmeik Driggins, 19, says that Ralph Carnegary, 63, was the aggressor, punching her in the face after she came to the defense of her girlfriend Sheila Figeroa, her lawyer said Monday.

    Eight women were arrested after the wild melee on the 6 train Sunday, but only six were charged.

    Manhattan prosecutors say the group attacked Carnegary after they overheard him tell a friend, “Those girls must be retarded because they can’t hear each other talk.”


    • Pandemonium

      “Those girls must be retarded because they can’t hear each other talk.”

      Nope, they’re retarded because of what they are.

  • Up to my neck in CA

    “…that the women, beers in hand, were yelling: ‘We didn’t do anything!’ as they were being cuffed.”

    I believe that was “we didn’t do nuffin!!”

    I like how one of them is smiling in the picture.

  • Sheila Dinehart

    such sweet young ladies

  • vladdy1

    What do you think the odds are that they have offspring already?