Posted on October 16, 2019

17,000 Sign Petition Demanding BBC Removes Expose Because It’s ‘Disrespectful’ to Shia Islam

Martin Robinson, Daily Mail, October 15, 2019

More than 17,000 people have demanded the BBC take down a documentary about young Iraqi girls being sold for sex — calling it ‘disrespectful’ to law-abiding Shia Muslims.

The corporation broadcast ‘Undercover With The Clerics — Iraq‘s Secret Sex Trade’ on October 3 — an investigation into sexual exploitation of children and young women by clerics in Iraq.

Journalists caught clerics offering ‘pleasure marriages’ to girls as young as nine — where men banned from sex outside marriage can pay a dowry for an interim wife.

The practice is banned in Iraq but eight out of 10 Shia clerics who were approached were willing to carry it out, the BBC World investigation found.

But now more than 17,000 people have signed an e-petition demanding the BBC removes the show from iPlayer.

The petition to the petition — set up by ‘Mo K’ — accused the corporation of ‘cherry-picking’ […] ‘misguided men who do not represent Shia Islam in any way’.

But a BBC spokesman told MailOnline it won’t be deleted and said: ‘This thorough investigation was conducted over an 11-month period and exposes the sexual exploitation of children and young women. The documentary fully complies with BBC Editorial Guidelines.’

The petition said the programme was made to ‘tarnish the image of Iraq and Shias worldwide’.

It claimed the women and girls in the show ‘did not know that it was being used to belittle Shia Islam’ and their words ‘would be used against their faith’.

The petition reads: ‘To the BBC. When we asked for representation, we weren’t expecting this mockery.

‘The BBC have recently published a documentary titled ‘Iraq’s Secret Sex Trade’, in which they go undercover to reveal the heinous crimes committed by a number of men who claim to follow the Shia faith.

‘Instead of making a documentary about the world’s largest, peaceful, annual pilgrimage held in Iraq, hosting 20 million people each year; the BBC have decided to cherry-pick a handful of misguided men who do not represent Shia Islam in any way, shape or form to tarnish the image of Iraq and Shias worldwide.

‘Please sign this petition if you stand with the Shia Muslims who feel that their religion is being gravely misunderstood.

‘This is not just embarrassing, it is the utmost disrespect.

‘To implicitly label us all as compliant with child prostitution is an absolute disgrace.

‘Those who partake in these acts are not our Shias.’

A petition has been signed by 17,000 calling for the BBC to remove it iPlayer — but the corporation is standing firm

As part of the show, BBC Arabic’s Nawal Al-Maghafi explored claims since 2003, Iraqi women have been trapped into prostitution and pimped out by the religious elite.

One young widow alleged that a cleric sold her to his friends in a prostitution ring, while secret filming revealed another cleric conducting a ‘pleasure marriage’ with a girl, 13.

In Karbala, Iraq’s most important religious city, the undercover reporter is introduced to a cleric who claims pleasure marriage with a child is halal: ‘Nine years old plus, there’s no problem.’

Footage showed him explaining: ‘It’s up to you how you want to do it, she’s permitted to you. You’re allowed to perform from behind. Do what you desire.’

Two of the three clerics secretly filmed by BBC Arabic describe themselves as followers of Ayatollah Sistani, one of the most senior figures in Shia Islam.

However, in a statement to the BBC, as part of the show, the Ayatollah said: ‘If these practices are happening in the way you are saying then we condemn them unreservedly.

‘Temporary marriage is not allowed as a tool to sell sex in a way that belittles the dignity and humanity of women.’

But thousands have slammed the BBC for allegedly tarnishing Islam ‘on national television at prime time on Friday evenings’ by signing the petition.

The petition accused the programme of ignoring the ‘world’s largest, peaceful, annual pilgrimage held in Iraq, hosting 20 million people each year’.