Inside a Chinese Test-Prep Factory

Brook Larmer, New York Times, December 31, 2014

The main street of Maotanchang, a secluded town in the furrowed hills of eastern China’s Anhui province, was nearly deserted. A man dozed on a motorized rickshaw, while two old women with hoes shuffled toward the rice paddies outside town. It was 11:44 on a Sunday morning last spring, and the row of shops selling food, tea and books by the pound stood empty. Even the town’s sacred tree lured no supplicants; beneath its broad limbs, a single bundle of incense smoldered on a pile of ash.

One minute later, at precisely 11:45, the stillness was shattered. Thousands of teenagers swarmed out of the towering front gate of Maotanchang High School. Many of them wore identical black-and-white Windbreakers emblazoned with the slogan, in English, “I believe it, I can do it.” It was lunchtime at one of China’s most secretive “cram schools”–a memorization factory where 20,000 students, or four times the town’s official population, train round the clock for China’s national college-entrance examination, known as the gaokao. The grueling test, which is administered every June over two or three days (depending on the province), is the lone criterion for admission to Chinese universities. For the students at Maotanchang, most of whom come from rural areas, it offers the promise of a life beyond the fields and the factories, of families’ fortunes transformed by hard work and high scores.

Yang Wei, a 12th grader at this public school, steered me through the crowd. A peach farmer’s son in half-laced high-tops, Yang had spent the previous three years, weekends included, stumbling to his first class at 6:20 in the morning and returning to his room only after the end of his last class at 10:50 at night. Yang and I met at this precise moment, after his Sunday-morning practice test, because it was the only free time he had all week–a single three-hour reprieve. Now, with the gaokao just 69 days away–the number appeared on countdown calendars all over town–Yang had entered the final, frenetic stretch. “If you connected all of the practice tests I’ve taken over the past three years,” he told me with a bitter laugh, “they would wrap all the way around the world.”

Yang and I had communicated on social media for weeks, and the 18-year-old seemed almost giddy to be hosting an American expatriate. Yet there was a crisis brewing. Even with all the relentless practice, Yang’s scores were slipping, a fact that clouded over the lunch I ate with his family in the single room that he and his mother shared near the sacred tree. We were joined by Yang’s father, visiting for the afternoon, and his closest friend from his home village, a classmate named Cao Yingsheng–all squeezed into a space barely big enough for a bunk bed, a desk and a rice cooker. The room’s rent, however, was high, rivaling rates in downtown Beijing, and it represented only part of the sacrifice Yang’s parents made to help him, their only son, become the first family member to attend college.

Yang’s mother, Lin Jiamin, quit her garment-factory job to support him in his final year of cramming. Cao’s mother came to live with her son as well. “It’s a lot of pressure,” said Cao, whose family paid more in school fees than Yang’s family–about $2,000 a semester–because of his low marks entering high school. “My mother constantly reminds me that I have to study hard, because my father is out working construction far from home to pay my school fees.” The room went quiet for a minute. They all knew this was the boys’ fate, too, if they failed to do well on the gaokao. “Dagong,” Yang said. “Manual labor.” He and Cao would have to join China’s 260-million-strong army of migrant workers.

{snip}

Nothing consumes the lives of Chinese families more than the ever-­looming prospect of the gaokao. The exam–there are two versions, one focused on science, the other on humanities–is the modern incarnation of the imperial keju, generally regarded as the world’s first standardized test. For more than 1,300 years, into the early 20th century, the keju funneled young men into China’s civil service. Today, more than nine million students take the gaokao each year (fewer than 3.5 million, combined, take the SAT and the ACT). But the pressure to start memorizing and regurgitating facts weighs on Chinese students from the moment they enter elementary school. Even at the liberal bilingual kindergarten my sons attended in Beijing, Chinese parents pushed their 5-year-olds to learn multiplication tables and proper Chinese and English syntax, lest their children fall behind their peers in first grade. “To be honest,” one of my Chinese friends, a new mother, told me, “the gaokao race really begins at birth.”

China’s treadmill of standardized tests has produced, along with high levels of literacy and government control, some of the world’s most scarily proficient test-takers. Shanghai high-school students have dominated the last two cycles of the Program for International Student Assessment exam, leading more than one U.S. official to connect this to a broader “Sputnik moment” of coming Chinese superiority. Yet even as American educators try to divine the secret of China’s test-taking prowess, the gaokao is coming under fire in China as an anachronism that stifles innovative thought and puts excessive pressure on students. Teenage suicide rates tend to rise as the gaokao nears. Two years ago, a student posted a shocking photograph online: a public high-school classroom full of students hunched over books, all hooked up to intravenous drips to give them the strength to keep studying.

{snip}

Even as cram schools have proliferated across urban areas, Maotanchang is a world apart, a remote one-industry town that produces test-taking machines with the same single-minded commitment that other Chinese towns devote to making socks or Christmas ornaments. {snip}

Isolated in the foothills of Anhui, two hours from the nearest city, Maotanchang caters mostly to such students and prides itself on eliminating the distractions of modern life. Cellphones and laptops are forbidden; the dormitories, where roughly half the students live, were designed without electrical outlets. Romance is banned. In town, where the rest of the students live, mostly with their mothers in tiny partitioned rooms, the local government has shut down all forms of entertainment. This may be the only town in China with no video arcade, billiards hall or Internet cafe. “There’s nothing to do but study,” Yang says.

Town planning is not the only means through which the school instills discipline in kids like Yang, a normally fun-loving teenager from Yuejin whom his father calls “the most mischievous kid in the village.” Maotanchang’s all-male corps of head teachers doles out lessons, and frequently punishments, with military rigor; their job security and bonuses depend on raising their students’ test scores. Security guards roam the 165-acre campus in golf carts and on motorcycles, while surveillance cameras track students’ movements in classrooms, dormitories and even the town’s main intersections. This “closed management practice,” as an assistant principal, Li Zhenhua, has termed it, gets results. In 1998, only 98 Maotanchang students achieved the minimum gaokao score needed to enter a university. Fifteen years later, 9,312 students passed, and the school was striving to break the 10,000 mark in 2014. Yang and Cao hoped to be among them.

{snip}

Yang’s parents and I lingered in front of the rows of dormitories where their son spent his first two years at Maotanchang. Ten students, sometimes 12, bunked in each room. The wire mesh covering the windows–“to prevent suicide,” one student told me later, only half-joking–was festooned with drying socks, underwear, T-shirts and shoes. The dorms have few amenities–no electrical outlets, no laundry room, not even, until a separate bathhouse was installed last year, hot water. There is, students note, one high-tech device: an electronic fingerprint scanner that teachers log into every night to verify that they have conducted their obligatory bed checks.

{snip}

The head teachers’ schedules are so grueling–17-hour days monitoring classes of 100 to 170 students–that the school has decreed that only young, single men can fill the job. The competition to hang onto these spots is intense. Charts posted on the walls of the faculty room rank classes by cumulative test scores from week to week. Teachers whose classes finish in last place at year’s end can expect to be fired. It’s no wonder that teachers’ motivational methods can be tough. Besides rapping knuckles with rulers, students told me, some teachers pit them against one another in practice-test “death matches”–the losers must remain standing all morning. In one much-discussed case, the mother of a tardy student was forced to stand outside her son’s class for a week as punishment. For the repeat students, the teachers have a merciless mantra: “Always remember your failure!”

{snip}

When I returned to Maotanchang in June, the night before the students’ mass departure for the gaokao, the darkened sky was illuminated by dozens of floating paper lanterns. The ethereal orange orbs rose higher and higher, until they formed a constellation of hope. I followed the trail of lanterns to their source: an empty lot near the school’s side gate. There, several families were lighting oiled wads of cloth. As the expanding heat lifted their lanterns off the ground, their prayers grew louder. “Please, take my son past the line!” one mother intoned.

As the glowing lanterns soared unobstructed into the night air, families cheered. One lantern, however, became tangled in electrical lines. The student’s mother looked devastated–for this, according to local belief, was a bad omen, all but dooming her child to finishing “below the line” on the gaokao.

For a town that turns test preparation into a mechanical act of memorization and regurgitation, Maotanchang remains a place of desperate faith and superstition. Most students have a talisman of some sort, whether it’s red underwear (red clothing is believed to be lucky), shoes from a company called Anta (their check-mark logo is reminiscent of a correct answer) or a pouch of “brain rejuvenating” tea bought from vendors outside the school gates. The town’s best-selling nutritional supplements are called Clear Mind and Six Walnuts (the nuts are considered mind-boosters in large part because they resemble brains). Yang’s parents did not seem especially superstitious, but they paid high rent to live close to the mystical tree and its three-foot-high pile of incense ash. “If you don’t pray to the tree, you can’t pass,” Yang says, repeating a local saying.

{snip}

The 10,000 or so parents who come to live in Maotanchang will do almost anything to enhance their children’s chances on the gaokao. Many of the mothers, like Lin, lack formal education. Yet they are the fiercest enforcers of the unwritten rules that forbid Maotanchang residents to watch television, do laundry or wash dishes during students’ sleeping time. When an Internet cafe opened in town a few years ago, posing a potential distraction to students, the mothers helped the school carry out a boycott that eventually forced it to close. When Yang’s scores slipped, his mother confiscated his cellphone and made him study late at night while she sat next to him, weaving needlepoint slippers with butterfly and fish designs. During the day, Lin timed her cooking to coincide precisely with class breaks, so her son could devour his meals without wasting a second of study time. “We have to do all we can,” Lin said. “Otherwise, we will always blame ourselves.”

{snip}

Topics: ,

Share This

We welcome comments that add information or perspective, and we encourage polite debate. If you log in with a social media account, your comment should appear immediately. If you prefer to remain anonymous, you may comment as a guest, using a name and an e-mail address of convenience. Your comment will be moderated.
  • Speaking of, the blogger Education Realist has had a good series lately about how the international SAT test administration should be taken with a grain of salt.

  • David Ashton

    An instructive case of Yin and Yang.

    As Chairman Mao, he say: “If you go to top of red mountain, you must come down later.”

  • JohnEngelman

    This is sad. Growing evidence indicates that native intelligence matters much more than long hours of study. Some guys have it. Some guys never will.

    • El Baga Doucha Libtard

      It is rearry, rearry, a-sad!

      I think that I’ll go pray (that this nonsense stops) to the mystical tree.

    • Georgia Boy

      Agreed, there is nothing honorable about spending your whole life trying to do something that you don’t have the right gifts for. The comments to the article had a guy saying the math portion of the test is about equivalent in difficulty to the GRE. I took the GRE and I can’t imagine spending three years doing nothing but cramming for it. I would be so bored I’d be brain-dead by the end. I did test prep courses for the SAT too, and it didn’t make a huge difference in my score, 70 points improvement from PSAT to SAT. (Edit: this was in the days where 1600 was the max score.)

    • dmxinc

      True, but as the saying goes “The harder I work, the luckier I get.”

      Hard work will pay off. These people do not seem happy though. Reduced to the level of ants in a colony. They may dominate the world, but it will be a hollow victory for most.

  • Lygeia

    “They paid high rent to live close to the mystical tree and its three-foot-high pile of incense ash.

    ‘If you don’t pray to the tree, you can’t pass,’ Yang says, repeating a local saying.”

    These are the people we think are smarter than us? You have to study and be intelligent (perhaps I have reversed the order). Praying to a tree won’t do it.

  • Paul

    That’s odd Jared, I thought Asians were ‘simpler better programmers’

  • Anglokraut

    But the students who do pass the exams, what do the universities teach that the incoming Freshmen aren’t required to know already? Why have universities at all?

    • John Smith

      That’s supposedly like Japan, where secondary school is harder than university and the students somewhat coast after they attend college.

  • FozzieT

    This article is fascinating, and demonstrates how much racial evolution influences the culture. This type of situation could not even be conceived in an African culture, nor in an American Indian/Mestizo culture. I could see a “lite” version of it in European culture (think English boarding schools and such).

    In fact, I couldn’t imagine a White, much less an African, raised their entire lives in a Chinese household, being able to succeed in this type of environment. But the Chinese do it.

    • Ultimate187

      I think White children raised in that kind of high stakes environment would sufficiently adapt. Intelligence and more importantly, work ethic, are the two limiting factors which would make it less likely for Africans, Mestizos etc to thrive in that culture.

  • LHathaway

    “The astonishing lengths to which Chinese will go to get into college”.
    I didn’t know Chinese boys were obsessed with white girls. . . Maybe white boys in the USA should be obsessed with getting one. If they were their grades might go up.

    • Ultimate187

      The article is talking about Chinese students getting into Chinese colleges, not western ones.

      • LHathaway

        Who knows, that may be a stepping stone into the west at this point. .

  • Seminumerical

    These rote memorization exams have a long history. An interesting read is China’s Examination Hell: The Civil Service Examinations of Imperial China. Some would take the exam every few years, some not passing until they were in their 70s.

    A classmate of mine graduated the top student in a 5000 student Chinese magnet high school for science and tech. They were allowed two half days a week of personal time. She told me she just slept on her time off. Bizarrely her entire last year of high school was a review of the preceding years.

    I took her with me as a teammate to an ACM programming competition. She surprised me when we needed a grade nine formula that I had never bothered to memorize, by closing her eyes for a moment and then reciting it. (It was Heron’s formula). The ACM is “open book,” I had a copy of Beta Mathematician’s Handbook with me, so I thought at the time that it was a bit of a useless skill.

    I assigned her the problem of finding a point in a polygon that had a certain property. Try to imagine checking every point on a line to the finest resolution that a computer provides. Then square the amount of time that takes to check every point on a plane. A major clue that that won’t work is that we were allowed only two minutes of CPU time on a rather slow computer. Her solution didn’t work.

    The whole point of the ACM programming competition is that you can’t look up the answer in a book (so you can’t memorize it). The team that carried in a stack of 40 reference books walked out shamefacedly after only three hours.

    (My own problem was to count the number of prime factors of n! for an unknown number of numbers n where n can be as large as one million. But I am showing off).

    When she got an A- in a programming course she came over to my digs. I was chopping veg and chicken for a stir fry. She picked up my sushi knife and held it to her throat. She had that same mad look in her eye that I once saw in a terrier that had been locked up in a cage too small to turn around in for 23 hours a day for months.

    The dean intervened and raised her grade to A, arguing that since English was her second language she was at a disadvantage.

    • dmxinc

      Interesting story.

      What is your take on China dominating the world?

      The have the size, the numbers, resources, obviously the work ethic and the IQ.

      What’s left to stop them? Cultural flaws perhaps? Or maybe we can encourage “diversity”?

      • Seminumerical

        I think that thousands of years of a ruling class that is the product of competitive exams that emphasize memorization and that punish originality (see the book on civil service exams that I mention above) has had the expected Darwinian effect.

        The threat is not so much China as America imploding Soviet Union style from an excess of crackpot leftist ideas and from an imported ethnic minorities problem.

        By the time China gets its aircraft carrier fleet up and running the carrier will be as obsolete as the battleship, and America, if there still is a healthy America, will be launching Mach 5 fighter drones off something like the Zumwalt-class destroyer.

        • anony

          “…and America, if there still is a healthy America, will be launching Mach 5 fighter drones off something like the Zumwalt-class destroyer.”

          These UAVs will be carrying conventional bombs the size of a can of soup that will be able to sink one of their aircraft carriers.

  • Ultimate187

    The infamous gaokao is the updated version of China’s Imperial Examinations. Going to university in China is a privilege, especially for those from poor or rural backgrounds, and these exams literally make and break futures. China’s education system is less about education, and more about the sorting and selection of good students. The reason children of Chinese immigrants are successful in school here is because it’s relatively easy in comparison to what they’re used to.

  • Deiter Botha

    This article is bullshit. Most of the events and actions described are probably false or exaggerated. Time and again we are told that some culture or another is nipping at our heels and that we better be more like them. Usually, as in this article it implies by comparison that we are lazy and or stupid. I have seen it many times before, cultural nut hugging. China is a filthy, savage, backward nation that will implode as soon as the communist government fails to provide all that we have. Can we do better yes but China sure as hell isn’t a role model.

    • Ultimate187

      It’s real. The BBC even made a documentary about it a few years ago.

      • Deiter Botha

        I question the lack of perspective not the fact that it exists. People are people and a sucker journalist is born every minute.

        • Ultimate187

          Unless you can offer a credible, alternative perspective instead of speculation, then there’s really nothing left to say.

          • Deiter Botha

            I don’t have to offer a credible alternative, this is a comments section moron.

          • Ultimate187

            You’re not offering because you don’t have one. You doubt the account of events because it doesn’t necessarily fit neatly with your negative stereotypes about China. Being a race realist doesn’t mean hating other cultures.

          • John Smith

            Chinese people are, perhaps, a little smarter than the European average, but one wonders how much of that difference is determined by who was tested and who was excluded. That said, population intelligence follows the same Gaussian distributions as anywhere else and these students, while maybe possessed of a better knowledge of facts, are still roughly the same intellect as students elsewhere, in developed countries. When you have 1.3 billion people, even if they were, on average, dumber, you still have a large number of smart people, compared to Europe and the US/Canada and their smaller combined population.

          • Proletarian Contemplations

            Yes, the Chinese have a higher mean IQ than whites.

      • anony

        The BBC is not my standard for truth and factual reporting.

    • Tarczan

      I sure didn’t think that this story demonstrated China’s coming superiority. I thought the opposite. These people are a bunch of drones who have any creative thought drummed out of them.

      It is obvious this type of training will not lead to future inventions. Read about the Wright brothers sometime, They just had that creative spark along with natural intelligence.

  • dmxinc

    Valid points.

  • JohnEngelman

    There is a third alternative. Behave decently. Perform adequately. Try not to want what you cannot have.

    Recognize and cultivate your talents. Do not waste effort on what you cannot achieve.

  • JohnEngelman

    The greatest disaster is not to find contentment.

    The greatest mistake is to desire for endless possession.

    Hence, when one is gratified with self-contentment,

    True contentment can then long endure.

    – Lao Tsu, from Tao Te Ching, Chapter Forty-Six

  • John Smith

    I bought books and self-tutored for my SAT (not doing anything for the ACT, which I took cold), since this was prior to the test-prep era that has swept across the country since then and did well. I took the GRE and got about the same scores I got on the SAT (out of 800) per the Q & V subsections with minimal prior prep. Supposedly Mensa and other intelligence-based groups refuse to take current SATs and other standardized tests since the late-’90s refurbishments many went through that they feel no longer constitute a test of intellectual ability (if they ever did).

  • shmo123

    The Chinese basis of education seems to be based on rote memorization, which may be beneficial for some professions–I’m still trying to think of one– but produces mainly robots. The how and why of things doesn’t come into play, which is why we’ll always be a few steps ahead of Asia technologically–unless or until multiculturalism destroys us. They’ll always produce enough hackers and computer nerds bright enough to steal western technology, but so far, they haven’t come up with any of their own.

  • Usually Much Calmer

    Upper class whites would then engage in juvenile delinquency to signal their status in your scenario.