Posted on December 6, 2019

Kids in Defense of the Culture

Pedro Gonzalez, Crisis Magazine, December 5, 2019

The shock troops against Conservatism, Inc. have arrived. Witness the rise of the groypers.

These cowboys sent people ducking beneath barstools the moment they set a spurred boot in the Culture War saloon. It has been amusing, to say the least, but not everyone is laughing. Some have even warned that the pale rider of fascism trots alongside them, evidenced by the irreverent humor of YouTube host Nicholas Fuentes—the Steven Colbert of reactionary youth.


So, who are the groypers? “They are mostly young Christians who care about the country and feel like the conservative establishment is not supporting policies that put America first,” says Jaden McNeil. Mr. McNeil is the former president of the Kansas State University chapter of Turning Point, USA. McNeil recently resigned from TPUSA after he and his colleagues concluded that the organization does not represent their values.

“I think Conservatism, Inc is terrified,” McNeil told me, “and I don’t see this slowing down until they stop selling out for donors at the expense of the American people.” {snip}

I asked one groyper—we’ll call him “John”—to outline for me some basic policy points from his perch in Washington, DC, where he works as a consultant.

To start, their foreign policy views can be altogether summarized in one word: “No.” This outlook has labeled them naïve at best and “anti-Semitic” at worst, all because they dare to oppose neoconservative foreign policy. {snip}


He says that they are deeply skeptical of “abstract principles and dogmas” that take the place of good sense. In the same way that they don’t believe in spreading democracy by the sword around the world, groypers do not have a sacred cow in free trade. They see “bastard capitalism” as a subversive, post-national force that merely produces consumers, not patriots. “Who,” as James Burnham asked, “would give his life for the GNP?” Not groypers.


Naturally, they believe that the government has a legitimate role in looking after people, contra the conservative ideologues who proclaim—as Turning Point USA founder Charlie Kirk has—that “it is not government’s role to take care of its citizens.” Groypers trust Kirk’s maxims about as far as they can throw him. Indeed, mistrust is a central theme of this movement: mistrust of political orthodoxy, of self-evident truths, and of institutions. John tells me that their “mistrust in the system” is only reinforced by the “media getting everything wrong when it comes to them.” The Q&A sessions from Kirk’s “Culture War” tour illustrate this problem.


Then came a sable-haired groyper with the complexion of an Arabica bean. How can America, he asked, retain its foundational Anglo-American culture in the era of mass immigration? Kirk brilliantly fired back by charging him with holding “racist” ideas. Next question.

It seems like whenever groypers speak, no one actually hears what they are saying. Every question, and certainly every joke, becomes an opportunity for a strawman that distracts from meaningful discussion. {snip}

Whatever can be said of their flaws, groypers ought to give us hope for a more authentic politics. These kids see through the paper tigers on the Fox News circuit and are thoroughly dissatisfied with the fair-weather conservatism that dominates the mainstream. {snip}

More importantly, they are passionate about ethical and moral questions, well-read on the issues, and intellectually curious. They recognize that a spiritually void, metapolitically incorrect movement is worthless: it stands on nothing, so it can stand for nothing. They have chosen to be guided by a Christianity hammered free of the dross of the modern world. In an age of compromise and petty principles, groypers have chosen to stand for something, armed with little more than digital slingshots. That alone is reason enough to hear them out.