Posted on October 11, 2018

Ginsburg Delays Fight over Census Citizenship

WorldNetDaily, October 10, 2018

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Ruth Ginsburg has delayed two depositions of Trump administration officials that had been scheduled by a judge hearing a case over whether the 2020 Census can ask respondents about their citizenship.

WND reported last week the federal government had asked for a stay of orders from a lower court that would have compelled a wide-ranging interview with Secretary of Commerce Wilbur Ross.

Critics of the citizenship question demanded to “probe the secretary’s mental state.”

The government asked Ginsburg, who hears emergency appeals from that part of the country, to at least delay them.

On Tuesday, she ordered that the deposition plans be stayed pending a response from opponents of the question or until a further order from her or the full court.

The questioning of President Trump’s appointee is unnecessary, the administration said. The government argued the Census previously included citizenship questions from 1820 to 1950, except for one time, and again from 1960 through 2000.


“The immediate dispute here is about whether respondents are entitled to probe Secretary Ross’s mental state – his subjective motivations – when he decided to reinstate the citizenship question. Secretary Ross consulted with many parties, including Census Bureau, Commerce Department, and Justice Department officials, before announcing his decision, and he set forth his reasons in a detailed memorandum backed by a voluminous administration record,” the filing states.


The Supreme Court, the filing argues, “has long recognized that an agency decisionmaker’s mental state is generally irrelevant to evaluating the legality of agency action … So too has this court recognized that compelling the testimony of a high-ranking government official – especially a member of the President’s Cabinet – is rarely if ever justified.”


Ginsberg denied a similar request from the government, but the federal attorneys returned on Tuesday and she granted their request.