A Pakistani immigrant allegedly beat his wife to death with a stick for making him the wrong dinner, a court heard.

Noor Hussein, 75, believed he had the right to discipline 66-year-old Nazar at their apartment in Brooklyn, New York, his defense said.

But prosecutors claim he murdered her because she had made the mistake of cooking him a vegetarian meal made of lentils instead of goat meat.

At the start of Hussein’s murder trial yesterday, a court heard the victim was left a ‘bloody mess’.

Court papers quoted by the New York Post said: ‘The defendant asked [his wife] to cook goat and [his wife] said she made something else.

‘The conversation got louder and his wife disrespected defendant by cursing at defendant and saying motherf***** and that the defendant took a wooden stick and hit her with it on her arm and mouth.’

Defense attorney Julie Clark said Hussein admitted beating his wife but said that in his home country, beating your wife is customary.

She argued that Hussein, who met his wife in Pakistan before the couple married and moved to Brooklyn, is guilty of only manslaughter because he didn’t intend to kill her.

In her opening statements at the Brooklyn Supreme Court bench trial, Clark said: ‘He comes from a culture where he thinks this is appropriate conduct, where he can hit his wife.

‘He culturally believed he had the right to hit his wife and discipline his wife.’

However, Assistant District Attorney Sabeeha Madni said: ‘This was not a man who was trying to discipline his wife.’

She said neighbours would testify to the ‘years of abuse’ Hussein’s wife suffered.

Madni said that on the day of her death, Hussein attacked his wife as she lay in her bed, leaving deep lacerations on her head, arms and shoulders, and causing her brain to hemorrhage.

Court papers state he beat her with a stick that the family had found in the street and used to stir their laundry in a washtub.

He then tried to clean up the blood that splattered onto their bedroom wall before calling his son for help, Madni said.

Topics: , , ,

Share This

We welcome comments that add information or perspective, and we encourage polite debate. If you log in with a social media account, your comment should appear immediately. If you prefer to remain anonymous, you may comment as a guest, using a name and an e-mail address of convenience. Your comment will be moderated.
  • Publius Pompilius Quitus

    Stupid peasants. Ignore this, and obsess about Boko Haram in Nigeria, so we can invade that country next.

    • Oil Can Harry

      Even worse, the feminazis here in NYC are ignoring this outrage and instead whining that the NY Times fired their first ever female editor because they’re “sexist”.

      As usual feminazis howl when white men so much as look at them funny but ignore blacks, hispanics and Muslims subjecting women to murder, rape, incest and female “circumcision”.

      • Truth Teller

        Not that I agree with everything they do but NOW stood up and made people aware of the Taliban even in the late 90s.

  • dd121

    He wanted goat? Well she got his goat. The primitive of Mohammed reaches new lows.

    • AndrewInterrupted

      He got his scapegoat. Let that diversity just wash over you, people.

      • Publius Pompilius Quitus

        Wonderful pun!

    • Oil Can Harry

      He killed his wife because when he asked for goat’s head soup she handed him a Rolling Stones album.

      [rimshot]

      • Extropico

        The lyrics of the delightful Star Star would be highly objectionable to the Muslim but murdering his wife would constitute a profound “honor” in his benighted, misogynistic culture.

    • borogirl54

      I hope he gets deported back to Pakistan but I doubt it.

    • Steven Bannister

      I’ve got a GREAT idea. Let’s execute him and claim that it’s OUR culture!

    • Anna Tree

      This is nothing new.
      “Prophet” mohamed himself hit Aisha, his third wife (the child bride):

      Sahih Muslim Book 004, Number 2127:
      […] ‘A’isha who had narrated […] “When it was my turn for Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon him) to spend the night with me, he turned his side, put on his mantle and took off his shoes and placed them near his feet, and spread the corner of his shawl on his bed and then lay down till he thought that I had gone to sleep. He took hold of his mantle slowly and put on the shoes slowly, and opened the door and went out and then closed it lightly. I covered my head, put on my veil and tightened my waist wrapper, and then went out following his steps till he reached Baqi’. He stood there and he stood for a long time. He then lifted his hands three times, and then returned and I also returned. He hastened his steps and I also hastened my steps. He ran and I too ran. He came (to the house) and I also came (to the house). I, however, preceded him and I entered (the house), and as I lay down in the bed, he (the Holy Prophet) entered the (house), and said: Why is it, O ‘A’isha, that you are out of breath? I said: There is nothing. He said: Tell me or the Subtle and the Aware would inform me. I said: Messenger of Allah, may my father and mother be ransom for you, and then I told him (the whole story). He said: Was it the darkness (of your shadow) that I saw in front of me? I said: Yes. He struck me on the chest which caused me pain, and then said: Did you think that Allah and His Apostle would deal unjustly with you?”

      And of course allah came up with a verse allowing muslims to hit their wives:
      The Quran, chapter 4 (An-Nisa), verse 34:
      “Men are in charge of women by [right of] what Allah has given one over the other and what they spend [for maintenance] from their wealth. So righteous women are devoutly obedient, guarding in [the husband’s] absence what Allah would have them guard. But those [wives] from whom you fear arrogance – [first] advise them; [then if they persist], forsake them in bed; and [finally], strike them. But if they obey you [once more], seek no means against them. Indeed, Allah is ever Exalted and Grand.”
      Translated by Abdullah Yusuf Ali

      • dd121

        Sounds like what the great prophet is describing is wife abuse and possibly child rape. Great religion those muzzies have.

  • David Ashton

    In a truly multicultural society having people for dinner literally could add a piquant vibrancy to rich diversity. I am waiting for the abortion lobbyists to put the bits of tasty and nutritious aborted fetus on plates rather than into the hospital heating systems. After all if dogs can get the placentas, the feminists could tuck into the babies.

    • saxonsun

      And you, Mr. Ashton, would heartily tuck into gays and feminists…or anyone else who doesn’t fit your idea of what a human should be. Talk about totalitarianism.

      • David Ashton

        An irrelevant jibe. I regard gays, feminists, non-white people and babies as all human, with a right to life and protection from violence; and I have never said anything else. None of them are “things” to be destroyed or eaten. Personally I am against the killing of viable and sentient humans, born or unborn. A fetus is sustained by its mother, but not part of her own body, though in the very rare occasion of pregnancy endangering the actual life of the mother I would support abortion as a necessary evil. I am not a woman, but I was a baby and have been a parent. However, I support eugenic contraception, which painlessly reduces harm.

        As for adult feminists and homosexuals I exercise my right to disagree – or agree – with their various views. I do not seek to harm them, or anyone else, physically. My opinion, open to revision, for what it is worth, is that being “gay” is neither an illness nor a sin, but a reproductive dysfunction caused by hormone dosage before birth, plus a genetic factor in many cases. However, some aspects of the “gay lifestyle” I regard as medically or socially undesirable, such as felching and the seduction of minors.

        Speech codes to prevent opinion or debate on “gays and feminists” are totalitarian. So your ignorant slur is also beside the point.

      • My mother’s neighbor passed away a few years ago. He was in the navy’s Underwater Demolition Team during World War Two. The pleasant son of Kansas farmers met the war and turned into what he should not have been. His son is gay, but I like the way his son takes care of his mother. I regard him as smart, honest, and only a little bit flawed.

        My own ex-father was a university professor who liked beating up women. I’m still hard of hearing from having fought too many hand grenade fights inside concrete buildings. My daughter wants to be an astronomer.

        You can’t pigeonhole people the way you seem to like. We are complex precisely because we are individuals.

        • David Ashton

          Get that autobiography written & published, Mr Scott. By the way, I think your “Red Indian” ancestry was comparable to Winston Churchill’s.

        • Martel

          I agree with David’s suggestion for an autobiography, I’m not always sure whether you are telling the truth, but if so, an autobiography would be very interesting and would definitely end up on my bookshelves.

          “A real life Breaking Bad(the TV series)” or something in that direction might be a promotional angle. Naturally, it should contain some of your sensible views on race.

          • If I was lying, I wouldn’t have admitted being a ex-con, and wouldn’t use my own name. I could say I was still a chemical engineer working in the microelectronics industry, and nobody here would know the difference. I could be working for Lockheed-Martin or RamTron in that case. The nice thing about telling the truth, however is that I don’t have to wonder which version to say.

          • David Ashton

            Good answer, but it would make a good story in any case.

      • Katherine McChesney

        You have a lousy attitude. You should go to a website that promotes and protects your perversion.

  • [Guest]

    >>>…In his [Noor Hussein’s] home country ________ is customary.

    People from primitive cultures should practice their own primitive customs in their own primitive lands—and not in mine.

  • NoMosqueHere

    But prosecutors claim he murdered her because she had made the mistake of cooking him a vegetarian meal made of lentils instead of goat meat.

    —————————————————

    I know, I get fightin’ mad when I don’t get my goat meat.

  • Luca

    DeBlasio will soon declare Sharia law in NYC anyway. It’s his Liberal solution to reducing the Muslim population in our jails.

    Next on the agenda, it will be legal for Muslims to marry an 11-year old cousin.

    • Diana Moon Glampers

      Correction: six years old, as endorsed by the prophet himself.

  • I can’t imagine hurting Sayaka. It wouldn’t occur to me. I love her enough that even if I were a vampire, I couldn’t bite her. The critter’s religion says women are slaves.

    Women are our friends.

    • saxonsun

      But only if they stay in that fake place that men have assigned them, otherwise they’re “feminazis” as one man puts it here.

      • Wholly Unconvinced

        My, you’re quite feisty today, did your “life partner” suddenly change gender again and dump you or something?

      • My wife works at Wells Fargo as a loan officer. I do almost all of the cooking and cleaning, as well as teaching our daughter. This is practical, as my FBI file says “firearms expert, explosives expert, chemist and ex-mercenary”. I am thus nearly unemployable, while Sayaka is not. Blackwater did not take ex-cons when I looked into going back to that sort of work.

        How could we – as men – possibly assign women – as women – a place that they do not want? I have nothing that I feel I need to prove in this respect. My best friends are almost all women. One can’t bully someone into being a friend. I’m not a smooth talker, but I am totally reliable. Sayaka likes reliability. My remaining friends appreciate reliability as well.

        I suspect you have assigned all men a role which we never wanted and most of us do not deserve.

      • Katherine McChesney

        You’re a man-hater aren’t you?

        There’s nothing worse than a female bully and you are the worst I’ve seen.

  • WR_the_realist

    It is a curious legal theory (and this is certainly not the first time it’s been used) that a defendant should get off lightly if he came from a foreign country where his illegal actions are considered acceptable. It doesn’t occur to people that if you choose to move into another country you are choosing to live under its laws.

    • GeneticsareDestiny

      But remember: it’s perfectly fine to hold white immigrants to our laws. It’s only when the immigrant (or “refugee”) is a member of the precious diversity that we’re supposed to be sympathetic about the fact that the criminal “didn’t understand” that his actions were illegal here, because the action was fine in his home country.

      And this, strangely enough, seems to go doubly for Muslim immigrants/refugees who commit crimes, particularly against women. It’s like Islam boosts someone up from merely “diverse” to “super-diverse” and thus makes it even more necessary that they be treated gently under the law.

      • Anna Tree

        And then there was a twist a few year ago, when a German judge citing the koranic verse 4:34 (I copy-pasted it in an earlier comment) caused a public outcry after she rejected the request for a fast-track divorce by a
        Moroccan-German woman because her husband beat her. The judge, who was removed from the case, wrote that the Koran sanctioned physical abuse.
        spiegel de/international/germany/justifying-marital-violence-a-german-judge-cites-koran-in-divorce-case-a-473017.html

        Maybe the judge was a liberal leftist but maybe she wasn’t: she was sending a message, that if you are a muslim, thinking islam is the best religion and wishing/trying to impose it in our white countries, then maybe you should live by its rules and not be enjoy and be protected by the western rules you want to destroy.

    • convairXF92

      Alan Dershowitz discusses this issue in his book *The Abuse Excuse*. He opposes letting such a defendant get off more lightly than an acculturated native citizen. His example was that of a Japanese mother in the US who walked straight out into the ocean holding her kids’ hands, until the kids drowned — apparently the mother, who had intended suicide by this means, survived and was put on trial. This “mother-child suicide” is a traditional form of suicide for women in Japan.

  • Ed

    If he gets the right liberal judge he may actually walk.

  • Diana Moon Glampers

    Cultural relativism.
    Who says civilization is superior to savagery?

  • borogirl54

    I wonder if he claimed that this is really an honor killing because she ruined his honor and cooked him a vegetarian meal.

  • Magician

    Whenever I hear an immigrant male murdering his own lover or wife it is in UK.

    • IstvanIN

      They murder ours.

  • JSS

    “In her opening statements at the Brooklyn Supreme Court bench trial, Clark said: ‘He comes from a culture where he thinks this is appropriate conduct, where he can hit his wife”.

    Oh that’s just a rich description of modern Amurrika, a likely femanzi lawyer defending a muslim wife killer. This is progress, this is the future.

  • IstvanIN

    Defense attorney Julie Clark Feminsts can be bizarre.

    Assistant District Attorney Sabeeha Madni What is that?????

  • What absolute filthy degenerates these creatures are. What kind of elderly monster beats his elderly wife to death with a stick. What kind of stick? Baseball bat? Where’d the stick come from? I have no sticks in my house. The “stick” had been used before, no doubt.

    This is just one of many test cases that will be argued this way. The first libtard judge who buys the defense will open a pandora’s box.

    Get these muzzie monsters out of here. They have no place in civilization.

    • GeneticsareDestiny

      It’s the stick he (or more likely, his wife) uses to move the laundry around in a tub. I suppose they don’t have a washing machine, and can’t afford (or aren’t aware of the existence of) the laundromat.

    • Anna Tree

      Some imams do say not to make the woman bleeds, but it’s their interpretation: the koran or mohamed don’t draw limits (see the verses I quoted in an earlier post), except maybe to say that don’t beat your wife like you beat your slave, or you won’t be able to have intercourse with her:
      Bukhari Volume 7, Book 62, Number 132:
      “The Prophet said, “None of you should flog his wife as he flogs a slave and then have sexual intercourse with her in the last part of the day.””

      There was a video on youtube about what exact size of a stick, a husband can use to beat his wife, but I don’t find it right now. The stick can be bigger than a thumb but smaller than the wrist…

      • The old “rule of thumb” in Western Europe meant that a man should never hit his wife with a stick thicker than his thumb. I can not imagine beating a woman. I would rather hang myself as unfit to live and just get it over with, instead. I am too strong to hit ladies. I am skinny, at six feet tall and 155 pounds, but I can lift and carry my end of an upright piano with my left hand.

        When Sayaka and I are done in the shower, we practice shaitsu, Japanese massage. I must be careful with her, as I love her very much. Most men are very much stronger than women, so shame on those who hit ladies.

        • Anna Tree

          Lucky Sayaka 😉


          The difference is that the old rule of thumb in Western Europe has become obsolete but beating the wife in muslim countries (and beyond) is and will always be okay because it is allowed in the koran and in mohamed’s sunnah, it cannot be challenged or even moderated as long as muslims follow islam because:

          A) allah claims in the koran that the koran is complete, perfect
          and eternel ( koran 5:15, 44:58, 54:22, 54:32, 54:40, 6:114, 5:16, 10:15, 2:2 etc) and clear and easy to understand (verses 54:17, 54:22, 54:32, 54:40). Whatever is written there is forever islamic and halal (allowed). It is why there are still slaves, child bride and jihad and wives-battery in the world/islam today. Additionaly,

          B) “prophet” mohamed is the uswa hasana (the model of conduct of excellence), the al insan al kamil (the perfect human), that is THE best man ever, THE guide to follow for all mankind, all time and all places (koran 68:4, 33:21, 60:4, 60:6), therefore whatever he did is islamic and halal, he had slaves, he raped women taken as booty of jihad, he killed Non-muslims who didn’t accept the superiority of islam and he beat his wife. It is why the sharia allows child brides, jihad and slavery. It is why the muslim countries didn’t sign the Declaration of Human Rights. it is why there are so many “terrorists”/”extremists” in islam or why there are so many videos and texts of imams advocating to beat one’s wife: they are just good muslims.

          Islamic morals are frozen in the “moral compass” provided by the koran and the behavior of a 7th century Bedouin warlord. To denounce or moderate, modernize, reform this moral compass is to destroy islam, that no muslims will do and some will kill those who do that (and they did kill, even in our non-muslim countries).

          • I would rather hang myself than hurt her. Since hanging myself would also hurt her, I suspect I am in a bit of a fix.

  • Mrfinoni

    he is 75. he will get a very light sentence. considering morality and ethics are now totally subjective I would suggest that Europeans should let go of values such as loyalty, honour, decency, respect as Obama and the New World Order have competing values. They have the values of the Harvard elite who now hold Black masses and worship Satan. I give them one thing. They are putting it out there for all to see. These are our values. This is who we worship. If you want to be part of our club get with the program.

  • Ahnenerbe ᛟ

    Too bad he didn’t kill her before they bred.

    • AndrewInterrupted

      Yeah, it’s a timing thing.

    • Truth Teller

      In other words, you are OK with this behavior yet use it to condemn them. Hmmm

      • Ahnenerbe ᛟ

        I could care less if pakis kill each other, they don’t belong in my ingroup.

        • Truth Teller

          You are OK with them killing one another because of their misogynistic behavior and then you support it when a woman gets killed from their misogynistic behavior. This is where your hypocrisy lies.

          • Ahnenerbe ᛟ

            Do you think pakis care when whites kill each other? You act like white people never kill their spouses

          • Truth Teller

            It’s not about not caring, it’s about you actually encouraging it and wanting it to happen. If you didn’t care you would just say you didn’t care about it instead of posting that gem you posted saying he should have killed her before she bred.

          • Ahnenerbe ᛟ

            Let me amend it, he should have killed himself after her killed her instead of breeding so the State does not have to pay for his court costs and incarceration while their paki runs around America breeding pakis

          • Truth Teller

            I agree then. People that act like that should be taken out of the gene pool via the death penalty.

  • Kenner

    Anyone that uptight needed to eat plenty of lentils.

  • connorhus

    I raise sheep. I had a co-worker the other day ask me why I don’t raise goats. Goats actually make a bit more money overall than sheep but I refuse to sell my stock into that particular market. So I raise sheep. It’s generally too expensive per pound for that particular market.

    • IstvanIN

      Too expensive for Muslims to eat or to date? I used to make lamb goulash in the crock pot when my daughter was in school. Dinner was ready when I got home from work.

      • connorhus

        Prolly Both 🙂

        I know Muslims raise sheep in the ME but here in the US the goat market is much larger and gets better prices at the livestock sale. I don’t know why except I have always heard the goat market goes mostly to the Muslims. Maybe it is different in other regions but around here goats pay out more at the sale barns.

      • Hallie Eva

        I make over the top delicious, slow cooked lamb shanks, Indian style. Fry thinly sliced onions until they are crisp for crumbling over a serving, if desired. Make peach/mango ginger chutney, too.
        About this Paki murderer. What is this animal doing in our country? [Rhetorical question].
        He should be locked up for life. I agree, if the female attorney’s son-in-law beat her daughter to death for cooking the wrong meal, would that be acceptable to her, and appropriate for a plead down to a lesser charge of manslaughter? I think not.
        No Muslim man, woman, or child, should be admitted here or to any European nation. Their
        ultimate goal is the establishment of world wide, inhumane, Sharia law, a proto-human system incompatible with civilized, Western civilization.
        Take a look at areas in this country were there are high concentrations of these 7th century regressives agitating for Sharia. Courts are softening their stance and allowing it.
        The fact that this monster attempted to cover his tracks by cleaning up the blood to obscure forensic evidence, means he knew he had broken our
        law.
        Do not be fooled. There is no such thing as a “moderate” Muslim. This man’s actions were not “radical;” they were in accordance with the Quran’s teachings.

  • Truth Teller

    A death penalty should be enforced worldwide for actions such as this. If the death penalty were enforced for all heinous crimes, genes for behaving this way will be taken out of the gene pool. If it is enforced worldwide, it will get the average down in all countries.

    • IstvanIN

      One world justice system? Hmmmm………not a good idea.

      • Truth Teller

        For some things there should be. Some laws should be worldwide, others by country, and others by state.

  • Truth Teller

    NOW tried to warn people about the Taliban back in the late 90s. Doesn’t anyone remember this?

    • IstvanIN

      If NOW had any sense they would be protesting all non-White/non-Christian immigration.

      • Einsatzgrenadier

        Feminism is all about hatred of white males. It has nothing to do with women’s rights. In the feminist universe, diversity is the only primary good because it is the most formidable weapon there is in the war against white male patriarchy.

        • saxonsun

          You are wrong on all counts. You are one of those men who’s terrified of strong women who know that their lives are their own to do with what THEY CHOOSE. If you only knew… And in reality, you are not really all that different from Muslim men.

          • Einsatzgrenadier

            How am I wrong on all counts? I have no problem with a free white woman, provided she is in touch with her natural instincts and can think for herself. I just don’t have any use for “strong women,” ideologically brainwashed, ball-busting, pro-diversity, typically lesbian feminists who scream “racism,” “sexism” and “discrimination” every opportunity they get. I suppose that’s you? And comparing me to disgusting, slimy Muslims. lol You do have a sense of humor.

          • She is angry at all men. We can’t fix that, so I would let her be.

          • Katherine McChesney

            You don’t come across as a strong woman. Actually you’re quite weak and you are a bully. You are a disgrace to the feminine gender. I’m ashamed that you are a woman. You’re too emotional. You should be medicated.

  • Caucasoid88

    It’d be culturally insensitive to incarcerate him. Now. now, let’s not be culturally biased.

  • Magician

    I wonder what the lawyer will say if a Pakistani person sexually and/or physically assaults her. Is it going to be a matter of “culture” and “true intention” as well?

  • IstvanIN

    If he had been in Pakistan, where he and his wife belonged, this would have been of no importance to the New York court system. This is the problem with allowing radically different immigration, our values are not theirs. While beating and killing one’s wife is wrong it shouldn’t be our problem. It is up to the sane women and sane men of Pakistan to end the acceptability of such behavior. I would venture to say that most Pakistani men and a plurality of women agree with this behavior.

  • fgbrunner3

    The old thug must be a moslem.

  • David Ashton

    Hilarious.

    You know the cartoon of two women in burkas at the airport, one saying to the other “Does my bomb look big in this?”

  • Einsatzgrenadier

    Islam is the vilest and most disgusting of the world’s great religions. It is a religion tailor-made for savages with seventh and eighth rate Stone Age minds. There are only two reasons for why anyone would embrace that ridiculous Stone Age religion: a defective genome and a low IQ, typically within the 70-85 range. Muslims are lower than human sewage. Muslims are generally the product of incestuous relationships. They even wipe their filthy arses with their own left hands, without using soap. The Koran, a confused and illiterate production, authorizes men to use brutal violence against their own wives, sexually molest prepubescent children and chop off hands for theft. Repulsive, inbred savages! I pity anyone who lives in close contact with those sick, twisted animals. Yet, the multicultural extremists in government, our supposedly enlightened rulers, annually import these animals into western countries by the hundreds of thousands in order to “culturally enrich” us. They couldn’t find worse racial replacements.

    • Bossman

      The sad thing is that this religion is said to be growing. Is that what they really do when they visit the toilet? I was always afraid to ask.

      • Yes Bossman thats what they do. They’re indeed below the subhuman level. They still think there back in the stone age!

  • 4321realist

    ” Hussein admitted beating his wife but said that in his home country, beating your wife is customary.”

    Well why didn’t he say so sooner before he was arrested?

    Now they’ll have to call off the trial, because he was in the right all along. The authorities didn’t know it was customary to beat a wife bloody in his culture. I’ll bet everybody in the DA’s office has a red face now. (Except the blacks)

    That explains everything.

    Gee, what an excellent defense.

  • model1911

    Don’t you all love diversity?

  • Valmont

    There must be plenty of women in NYC anxious to date a multi-culti widower with an apartment in Brooklyn. This guy is gonna be busy.

  • 2eRep

    I suspect he wanted the goat for sex and then dinner.

    • Q. What does one call a Muslim with a mixed flock of sheep and goats?

      A. Bisexual.

      • M.

        LMAO. Good stuff… Good stuff… Although a little racist.

  • 4teepee

    Obviously, the culturally insensitive prosecutors are racists.

  • SentryattheGate

    And don’t white men, in general, offer the best treatment of women? The most liberated women in the world are women in white countries; although it’s gotten too radical for our’s society’s good (and I say this as a woman). An example is domestic violence; black Americans have twice the domestic violence as whites, Hispanics commit 4 times the domestic violence (and Muslims even more, I’d guess)!

  • none of your business

    Murderer has been on old age SSI since he arrived in this country. Never contributed a dime but gets as much as Americans who have worked under social security for 40 years.

  • Does this mean Hussein won’t be getting his goat dinner? If so, his reaction appears to have been a suboptimal solution to his problem.