Identical Twins Need Never Be Tried for Same Crime After DNA Breakthrough

Sarah Knapton, Telegraph (London), December 11, 2013

Identical twins need never again be tried for the same crime after scientists found first proof that they are not genetically the same.

Forensic scientists have discovered there is a subtle genetic difference in the DNA of twins which were previously thought to be entirely identical.

The breakthrough means there is now a definitive test to find out which twin has been at the crime scene or has fathered a child.

In August detectives arrested Aftab and Mohammed Asghar, both 22, after recovering DNA from the jumper of 17–year–old girl who was allegedly attacked by at least three men in a Reading park at night.

However the prosecution eventually offered no evidence against Aftab when analysis of his mobile phone showed that he was in another location at the time of the alleged assault.

Until now geneticists have not been able to prove that identical twins–also known as monozygotic twins–are not genetically identical.

But in a breakthrough a forensic laboratory found the subtle difference at a genetic level which could prove vital in solving crimes and paternity cases involving identical twins.

Scientists used high tech sequencing of DNA from sperm samples from one set of twins and from a blood sample from a child of one of them.

Bioinformatics analysis in a forensics lab revealed five mutations, called “Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms” (SNPs) present in the twin father and the child, but not in the twin uncle.

The results suggest that rare mutations will occur early after or before the human blastocyst (a pre-embryonic form) has split in two – the origin of twins.

Dr Bruno Poddevin, Senior Vice-President of the Genomic Services division and head of the Forensics laboratory at Eurofins, said: “Eurofins scientists are the first to proof that monozygotic twins are genetically not absolutely identical.

“As the only provider worldwide Eurofins can now offer DNA forensic and paternity testing to discriminate identical twins to authorities, courts and individuals.

“Our leading genomic and forensic services team has provided the basis for reaching this milestone.

“As the first provider of next generation sequencing services in Europe, Eurofins also has proprietary, long expertise in the professional handling and analysis of the enormous amount of data involved in such a project.

“The dataset in this project equalled a total of 241 human genomes, resulting from up to 94 fold genomic coverage of the involved three individuals.”

The study was published in the journal Forensic Science International.

Topics: ,

Share This

We welcome comments that add information or perspective, and we encourage polite debate. If you log in with a social media account, your comment should appear immediately. If you prefer to remain anonymous, you may comment as a guest, using a name and an e-mail address of convenience. Your comment will be moderated.
  • dd121

    Hang ’em. Let God sort it out.

  • Puggg

    Yeah the science is a good enough story.

    But what are Aftab and Mohammed Asghar doing in Britain in the first place?

    • Spartacus

      Ensuring the rapenrichment.

  • cloudswrest

    This sounds like it is probably an expensive test. You can no longer rely on standard markers. You have to search the 3+ billion base pairs to find custom unique mutations for each twin pair.

    • Only if they have an identical twin, and only if the identical twin was possibly at the crime scene – or to state it horribly technically: “not provably not at the crime scene.”

  • Hunter Morrow

    Identical twins are a social construct…
    Deconstructed?
    Or constructed again?
    Mind blown.

  • IstvanIN

    This makes perfect sense. White science is amazing.

  • bigone4u

    Damn those scientists! Now I can’t blame my crimes on my imaginary identical twin brother, littleone4u.

  • If two guys are suspects for the same rape, it’s probably the one named Mohammad.

    • Mahound

      Could also be Ahmed.

  • Extropico

    Very interesting scientific discovery. Thanks to the editors for sharing.

  • Alexandra1973

    Next up on Maury….

    I’d always wondered about that, if you couldn’t figure out if that’s your father or your uncle.

    • rightrightright

      Easy. Bob’s your uncle.