Indigenous Fall Foul of Big-Stick Welfare Tactics

Patricia Karvelas, The Australian, November 22, 2011

Twenty per cent of all indigenous people on the dole have had their payments cut off because they failed to turn up to interviews in the first three months of the Gillard government’s new tough-love approach to welfare.

The Australian can reveal that in the three months since the government changed the dole rules, making it easier to dock all unemployed people’s payments, Aborigines have been hardest hit, incurring 20,020 suspensions.

But the big-stick approach has also meant that they are now turning up to more appointments than ever before because of fear they will lose welfare money, the government says.

The 20,020 suspensions from July to September were incurred by 13,768 jobseekers, who made up about 20 per cent of the 66,843 indigenous people who were unemployed. Only 1332 of the 20,020 suspensions lasted 14 days or more. Nationally, about 10 per cent of unemployed people incurred suspensions.

Canberra says early signs suggest that the new approach to compliance among Aborigines is already having a positive effect on attendance rates, which have increased by 3 per cent when compared with the corresponding three-month period last year. Whereas an average of 142,066 indigenous people attended appointments last financial year, 163,589 attended from July to September, since the rules changed.

The highest proportion of indigenous people who had their payments docked were in Queensland (29 per cent); followed by NSW (27 per cent).

Under the tougher dole rules, the first time a jobseeker fails to attend a Job Services Australia interview, Centrelink puts a temporary stop on dole payments. They start again once the jobseeker contacts Centrelink and confirms they will attend their rescheduled appointment. In the case of a first failure, full back-pay would then be provided.

The new rules allow employment-services providers to report jobseekers who have failed to attend Centrelink.

Employment Participation Minister Kate Ellis told The Australian businesses were crying out for workers and yet there remained too many Australians–including a disproportionate number of indigenous people–languishing on the dole queue.

“Earlier this year, our government introduced tough new rules that suspend income-support payments for unemployed people if they fail to show up at appointments or activities that are designed to help them find work.

“We have already seen positive early signs that this tough approach is making a difference, with more unemployed indigenous Australians showing up to their appointments and meeting their requirements over the past few months.”

Topics: ,

Share This

We welcome comments that add information or perspective, and we encourage polite debate. If you log in with a social media account, your comment should appear immediately. If you prefer to remain anonymous, you may comment as a guest, using a name and an e-mail address of convenience. Your comment will be moderated.
  • Anonymous

    Sounds like those smart white liberals in Australia have completely solved the problem!

  • Madison Grant

    I knew aborigines were shiftless but wow! When you don’t even put up an effort to show up for a free gov’t check that’s pretty bad.

  • Seneca the Younger

    I’m no expert on Australian politics, but I do know a thing or two about liberal white politics. How long will it take for the politicians in Oz to seem that this policy has a detrimental effect on a minority population and deemed racist or something along those lines.

    Much like the literacy tests we used to have in the U.S. way before I was born. Or, more currently, the drug tests for welfare recipients.

    Good idea, but will not last.

    And I hope I am wrong on that last part.

  • Tara C.

    seneca comment#3 – the australian govt already knows that welfare has had a detrimental affect on aboriginals but they dont know the solution. Many aboriginals freely acknowledge that welfare is destroying them.

    The ones cut off from welfare will get it back easily enough, but making their benefits depend on obeying the rules isnt a bad start.

    It was’nt always like this, welfare and automatic freebies have destroyed aboriginals.

  • GM (Australia)

    Reply to #3 (Seneca).

    This news has not been really mainstream here but will probably win votes for the party behind it. Both sides of politics here know that NO votes will come from pouring countless millions of dollars in to the Aboriginal problem. Having said this I should also point out that no government on this planet has been more generous than Australia in trying to help the plight of it’s indigenous peoples but always to no real beneficial effect. As one politician here infamously said, working in Aboriginal Affairs is a bit like cleaning the toilets on the Titanic! Officially he was reprimanded for saying this but most people agreed with his statement.

    Also relavant to this post is that the present slightly left leaning Labor Government here is committed to returning a budget surplus and and this will most certainly target welfare spending.

    Just by way of an explaination to other Amren followers; The Liberal Party of Australia is the Right and Conservative Side of politics.

    We also have the Greens as the 3rd aprty in Australian politics, yes, they would describe all of this as racist, discrimatory etc etc. They are totally against the present intervention in Aboriginal communities where part of their welfare payment is by way of vouchers that can only be redeemed for food and clothing, not alcohol or tobacco. (Racist scream the Greens!)