T. Keung Hui, News & Observer (Raleigh), Sept. 21, 2009
There’s no mistaking where the school board candidates in northern and eastern Wake County stand on hot-button issues such as student reassignment, school funding and the diversity policy.
Voters in District 1 who think the Wake school system is moving in the right direction and want to preserve the diversity policy will likely choose Rita Rakestraw, who has the backing of groups who support current policies.
But those who think Wake is out of control and spends too much time on busing can choose between Chris Malone and Debbie Vair.
The decision voters will make in two weeks in District 1 could help decide whether Wake continues its nationally recognized diversity policy or moves to a system of neighborhood schools.
“This is the most important school board election in 30 years,” said Rakestraw, a former teacher. “Our community is at a crossroads.”
The diversity policy has emerged as a sharp dividing line for the candidates. At issue is Wake’s practice of trying to balance the percentages of low-income students at each school, a policy that causes some students to be bused to more distant schools.
“Diversity is a fine thing,” said Malone, a former Wake Forest town commissioner. “We should strive to know more about other cultures and encourage understanding. But that has to be secondary to the primary goal of education.”
But for Rakestraw, keeping schools balanced is an important part of providing a high-quality education. She credits the diversity policy with keeping schools healthy, fueling economic growth and leading to Wake having a higher SAT score than the national average and a higher graduation rate than the state average.
Getting to diversity
Rakestraw warns that dropping the diversity policy will lead to resegregation and an increase in the number of high-poverty schools. She says that this would result in higher taxes to help fund those high-needs schools.
“It’s a good school system, but if we get rid of economic diversity, it’s going to be really harmful for the school system and the economy,” she said.
But Malone and Vair say concerns about resegregation are overblown. They say that allowing children to go to schools closer to where they live will help academics by increasing parental involvement.
“Our neighborhoods are diverse,” said Vair, a former school PTA president. “Diversity is something done in the ’60s. Our children need to stay in their neighborhoods. If any school has the right programs and teachers, it will succeed.”
Malone questions the success of the diversity policy by pointing to the recent decline in Wake’s overall graduation rate and how the district’s 54.6 percent graduation rate for low-income students is below the state average.
“I can’t imagine why they’re so proud to support a policy which is only graduating 54 percent of the group that they claim to be heroes for,” Malone said.