Justice Department Launches Investigation into Oakland Mayor

Abigail Miller, Daily Mail, March 2, 2018

The Department of Justice will review the actions of the Oakland mayor who tipped off undocumented immigrants last weekend about a planned raid by the Immigration and Customs Enforcement.

White House Press Secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders called the action by Oakland Mayor Libby Schaaf ‘outrageous’ in a press conference on Thursday.

‘I think it’s outrageous that a mayor would circumvent federal authorities and certainly put them in danger by making a move such as that,’ Sanders told reporters.

She said the move was ‘under review,’ but would not give more details.  The department will apparently look into whether her warning constitutes obstruction of justice.

Schaaf’s actions apparently kept more than 800 ‘criminals’ from being deported, according to Thomas Homan, ICE’s acting director.

She issued the warning on Twitter, a move which Homan called ‘beyond pale’ while speaking on Fox and Friends. He compared her to a gang lookout who tells people when a police car is arriving.

He said the Justice Department will review if Schaaf’s actions obstructed justice.

‘There’s over 800 significant public safety threat criminals, these are people who are here illegally and committed yet another crime, been convicted of a crime,’ he told Fox.

‘She gave them warning, and there’s 800 that we were unable to locate because of that warning, so that community’s a lot less safe than it would have been.’

Justin Berton, one of Schaaf’s spokespeople, told the Los Angeles Times his office isn’t aware of a review and declined to comment further. A Justice Department spokesman also declined comment to the Times.

The mayor defended her warning in a statement posted to Twitter Tuesday, and said she felt it was her duty to warn residents of the ICE action.

‘I do not regret sharing this information,’ she wrote.

‘It is Oakland’s legal right to be a sanctuary city and we have not broken any laws. We believe our community is safer when families stay together.

The unusual public warning came hours before the agency launched an operation in Northern California that resulted in more than 150 arrests as of Tuesday, according to the agency.

Homan’s statement on Fox of 800 missed targets — plus the 150 arrests — in only three days suggests an unusually large operation by the agency’s standards.

Two weeks ago, it arrested 212 in a five-day operation in the Los Angeles area. A Texas operation in February resulted in 145 arrests over seven days.

The agency said about half of the people arrested during the Northern California sweep have criminal convictions in addition to immigration violations, including convictions for assault, weapons offenses and driving under the influence.

It is impossible to independently verify that claim because the agency refuses to name them. Its statement identified only one arrest by name.

ICE declined to elaborate on the 800 who allegedly got away or answer other questions about the operation that began Sunday. Danielle Bennett, an agency spokeswoman, said more information would be released later in the week.

John Torres, the agency’s director during the end of George W. Bush’s administration and beginning of Barack Obama’s, said agents generally capture about 40 per cent of people they target in such sweeps.

Targets often elude authorities because agents don’t have search warrants and advocacy groups have waged public awareness campaigns urging people not to open their doors. Other times, agents have outdated addresses or targets are not home.

It was unclear how many people would have eluded capture without the mayor’s warning but Homan squarely blamed her for 800 and said her actions jeopardized officer safety.

Schaff on Saturday issued a statement on Twitter stating that she learned from ‘multiple credible sources’ that an immigration operation was imminent in the San Francisco area, including Oakland, possibly within 24 hours.

The mayor, who is running for another term this year, defended her actions again on Wednesday, saying she was not tipped off by ‘official sources’ and that she didn’t reveal specific locations.

Asked about Homan likening her to a gang lookout, she said the ‘Trump administration is trying to distract the American people, convince them that these immigrants are dangerous people. That could not be further from the truth and it is based in racism.

Lara Bazelon, an associate law professor at the University of San Francisco, said it was highly unlikely that the mayor would be prosecuted.

‘It’s a tall order for ICE to show that she was obstructing justice because they would have to show she knew they were going after specific people and I just don’t see the evidence for that,’ she said.

The warring words are the latest sign of escalating tension between California officials and the Trump administration over immigration enforcement and ‘sanctuary’ jurisdictions. Homan vowed that immigration agents would have a stronger presence in California since a state law took effect in January to sharply limit cooperation between state and local law enforcement and federal immigration authorities.

San Francisco Public Defender Jeff Adachi, who attended a protest outside the agency’s San Francisco office, said immigration officials did not respond to his demand that attorneys be allowed to interview people detained in the operation.

Booking logs at the Sacramento County jail show at least 12 people booked there by the agency on Sunday.

Dozens of protesters marching outside the agency’s offices in San Francisco after Homan spoke chanted, ‘Shut down ICE!’.

David Chiu, a Democratic state assemblyman, said Trump ‘has declared war on our immigrant communities.

‘We’re here to stand united and say we do not want him ripping apart our families, ripping apart our economy, ripping apart California,’ he said.

Homan, in announcing the arrests late Tuesday, renewed his warning that California’s limits on cooperating with ICE in local jails will lead to a bigger presence of immigration agents on the streets.

‘Sanctuary jurisdictions like San Francisco and Oakland shield dangerous criminal aliens from federal law enforcement at the expense of public safety,’ he said.

Defenders of so-called sanctuary city practices say they improve public safety by promoting trust among law enforcement and immigrant communities and reserving scarce police resources for other, more urgent crime-fighting needs.

Topics: , ,

Share This

We welcome comments that add information or perspective, and we encourage polite debate. If you log in with a social media account, your comment should appear immediately. If you prefer to remain anonymous, you may comment as a guest, using a name and an e-mail address of convenience. Your comment will be moderated.