Study: Va. Schools Suspend Black Male Students at Twice the Rate of White Males

Angela Ciolfi, UVA Today, December 18, 2013

A joint report released today by the University of Virginia’s Curry School of Education and Charlottesville’s Legal Aid Justice Center finds that in Virginia schools, black male students are twice as likely to be suspended as white male students. It also finds that most black students are being suspended for relatively minor misbehavior, such as being loud or disruptive in class.

The joint report also unveils the results of a new study demonstrating that use of the Virginia Student Threat Assessment Guidelines, developed by U.Va. professor Dewey Cornell, is associated with lower rates of school suspensions, including a smaller racial discipline gap. Schools using the guidelines have substantially lower rates of school suspensions, especially among black males.

Specifically, the report finds that:

  • Schools implementing threat assessment had smaller racial disparities in their long-term suspension rates; and
  • Threat assessment was associated with lower rates of out-of-school suspension overall: 15 percent fewer students received short-term suspensions and 25 percent fewer students received long-term suspensions in schools using threat assessment.

“In previous longitudinal studies, we found that suspension rates were markedly reduced when schools adopted the Virginia Student Threat Assessment Guidelines,” said Cornell, who led a Curry School team in conducting the study. “Our new cross-sectional study suggests a statewide impact involving more than 600 secondary schools with fewer suspensions for thousands of students.”

The threat assessment guidelines are used in several thousand schools in more than a dozen states, Cornell said, and also have been used in Canadian schools and as a model for programs in several European countries.

“Studies have found no support for the hypothesis that black students misbehave more often,” said Angela Ciolfi, the legal director of JustChildren, a child advocacy program of the Legal Aid Justice Center that provides free legal representation to low-income children families in Central Virginia. “In fact, racial disparities in suspension rates have raised increasing concern nationally because the data shows just the opposite – that black students are more likely to be suspended for more subjective and less serious reasons.”

The new report also provides practical tips for educators and law enforcement professionals implementing threat assessment and makes several policy recommendations, including requiring that schools ensure suspended and expelled students continue to make academic progress during periods of disciplinary removal.

In response to the tragic shootings at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Conn., Virginia became the first state in the country to mandate the formation of threat assessment teams in all its schools. Although the term “threat assessment” is unfamiliar to most educators, it is a violence prevention strategy that begins with an evaluation of persons who threaten to harm others and is followed by interventions designed to reduce the risk of violence.

A key aspect of threat assessment is its emphasis on considering the context and meaning of the student’s behavior and taking action that is proportionate to the seriousness of the student’s actions. This approach regards a threat as a sign of frustration or conflict that might be amenable to intervention, rather than simply a violation of rules that must be punished.

Currently, more than 1,000 of Virginia’s schools are using the guidelines.

Topics: ,

Share This

We welcome comments that add information or perspective, and we encourage polite debate. If you log in with a social media account, your comment should appear immediately. If you prefer to remain anonymous, you may comment as a guest, using a name and an e-mail address of convenience. Your comment will be moderated.
  • Puggg

    If the gap is only blacks twice that of whites, then they’re either suspending too few blacks or too many whites or a little of both.

    • GeneticsareDestiny

      It’s probably both. When I was in school, blacks could get away with selling drugs in class and beating each other nearly to death without getting suspended. But if a white student so much as wore a t-shirt with a bad word on it, he’d get an instant suspension.

      • Katherine McChesney

        I’m so grateful that I went to school during segregation. No dumb, dangerous blacks to worry about.

        • bilderbuster

          Good for you but please don’t rub it in our faces.
          They had to integrate our parents in the schools at the point of a bayonet & we didn’t like it either.

          • Zaporizhian Sich

            He has a point there Katherine.

          • Katherine McChesney

            I feel sad for you. My comment was not meant to insult you. I was merely making a statement after having extensive experience learning about how criminal that race is and why segretation made sense. It was to keep us safe from black criminality. The year integration began the parents in my small town put their resources together and founded a private Christian school. Gladly I recently discovered that after 46 years the school remains 100% White.

      • c684570

        Out of curiosity, what year was that, GeneticsareDestiny?

        • 1stworlder

          the same as demographics are destiny I would guess. Low IQ 3rdworlders would be able to be raised up if IQ was not genetic.

        • GeneticsareDestiny

          I graduated in 2012.

      • newscomments70

        ” But if a white student so much as wore a t-shirt with a bad word on it, he’d get an instant suspension.” An American flag, or a Christian symbol would do it as well. The confederate flag would be a prison sentence.

      • Yale2001

        True. Whites are held to a higher standard.

    • Garrett Brown

      They hardly punish blacks at all, and it’s definitely not to the same extent as whites if the situation is a majority black school.

    • 48224

      I was attending Detroit Public Schools when the forced busing started. Our 95% white school suddenly turned about 60% black and quickly turned into a crime ridden hell hole. My parents sent me to a private school for grades 9-12.

  • Let me make sure I understand this …

    If you redefine unacceptable behavior in the direction of leniency you will find yourself reporting fewer incidents of unacceptable behavior.

    Right. Got it. In fact, it this important principle may even apply to the general news reporting of certain kinds of crimes.

    • smedley

      It worked with Trayvon Martin, his burglary tools were downgraded to excessive gum chewing and he ain’t committing no more crimes.

      • c684570

        Yep! Trayvon’s crime were downgraded from theft to something like possession of stolen property, even though he had burglary tools.

        Wow, thinking back, the Trayvon case failed on every level possible to prove “White Racism”. Next time, try using a White guy at least, lol! Seeing as Zimmerman was Hispanic whose first language was Spanish.

        • bilderbuster

          I’ve been wondering how the Zimmerman’s felt about being called White?

          • c684570

            Or “White Hispanic”. He was White/Hispanic, as he was half and half. A “White Hispanic” would be, for example, a purebred Spanish person who was born in Latin America.

          • bilderbuster

            Zimmerman is a dark Metzito who was mostly referred to as White.
            I would like to know how his family & himself felt about this.
            It seems to me they kind of resisted this some because it might make him look less “guilty” of racism if he were “Hispanic”.

          • Anon

            Hispanic is a word only used in the United States.

            In spanish speaking countries as well as brasil, people are white, black, mestizo (mixed indian) or one of several pure bread indians. These groups do not mix.

            The fact that George is from the US effects his identity greatly. Although he looks mestizo to me, in peru, no one would ever consider him anything except white.

          • Katherine McChesney

            In New Mexico, the spanish settlers descendents are called Hispanics. They might qualify for the label “White Hispanic”. All who came from Mexico, Central and South America are referred to as Latinos. They and George Zimmerman are NOT “White Hispanics”. They have darker complexion.

          • Anon

            Probably pretty good. Like all these countries, the highest status class of peruvians are white. White defined by how much spanish blood one has. Most peruvians are mestizos……Zimmerman is probably a mesitizo (he looks just like a mexican immigrant).

            He also has some significant black in him…..spent most of his time helping out unfortunate black people.

            Zimmerman was a hard core liberal who wasn’t willing to give up being a man so he did manly things for a community that despises them. He violated the ultimate taboo among these sick jackasses and killed one of their gods (google the cambria will not yield blog if you don’t understand this). Everyone, including his wife, turned on him like a vicious pack of jackals. And some real crazy decided to screw his brains out in order to lie and get him thrown in jail.

            Zimmerman got the extra special, intensive boot camp course on liberalism. He should move to russia and join an immigrant murder squad.

        • Anon

          Actually, nothing of the sort happened. Trayvon was transferred out of the police jurisdiction by his school in order to interfere with his police investigation and likely imprisonment. He had a burglary tool (that tool….a slimjim, was actually found next to his cold dead corpse but not talked about by anyone). He had stolen jewerly. He got caught with drugs. He assaulted a municipal employee (20 years mandatory minimum, last time I checked). He was in ALOT of trouble. So the school took it upon itself to hide him by moving him to another school. Who knows what would have happened next but he uppsed his life of crime to attempted murder and Zimmerman killed him.

          • mharper42

            I read that Trayvon’s mother, whom he did NOT live with, sent him out of town to stay with his father during a school suspension. Schools do not have the authority to move a student to a different town.

      • Anon

        I’ve been saying this for awhile. Ignore their stupid argument. Buy and train in the use of guns. Carry guns. Kill criminals. One day, the government will collapse and then we will deal with the liberals in some harsh, inventive manner (like forcing them and all blacks to live together in a single state lik Florida behind an iron curtain).

        Five million times a year…..that’s how often a gun is used to stop a violent crime.

        Words……WORTHLESS. Guns….5 million times.

        Go buy a gun and lots of ammo. Go buy a better gun.

        • Bunky

          Hey, FU!
          Leave Fla alone dipwick.
          Send them to NY or Ca.

    • 1stworlder

      Don’t forget changing Hispanic crime to white

  • smedley

    Liberal speak for loud and disruptive in class – firing a gun, making appointments to send ya ho out to pick up you crack, beating up the elderly janitor who looked at you cross eyed.

  • dd121

    They can’t be educated and they can’t be civilized. Simple, really. ps don’t bore me with your exceptions. Of course there are.

    • bilderbuster

      There are a few exceptions but they don’t talk to each other because they don’t like Black people.

      • Anon

        Black people kill those “exceptions” on sight.

        • bilderbuster

          They’re usually purged from the projects before they’re old enough for elementary school.

        • Max Krakah

          Yes, it is like the zombies that take out the humans. Any human behavior or thought patterns marks them for immediate elimination.

  • Vyncennt

    Every single teacher I’ve spoken to….ever….both liberal and conservative….has testified to the fact that black children behave abhorrently in school. Every single one. No exception.

    It is the unspoken truth….that gets spoken….but only in private.

    • Oldcorporal

      A friend of mine here in Indiana (he’s now deceased) used to teach in a suburban school south of Indianapolis, which was forcibly integrated via “busing.” He told me that within a fairly short time after the forced busing began, the White students were picking up the blacks’ bad habits.

      • Vyncennt

        Yes, I’ve seen this in my city also. Bad habits have always been easier to implement than good ones.

      • Katherine McChesney

        White culture has been ‘negrofied’. High fives and other gang signals are used today. An elderly White woman two doors from my apartment used to call me “Girl” or ‘girlfriend’ like black women do. One day I told her I don’t appreciate her using these black expressions when addressing me.
        Since then she began to use my proper name.

        I refuse to behave or speak like ignorant blacks.

        • NotTooSwift

          You go, girl!

          Just kidding.

    • sbuffalonative

      My sister is a teacher and refuses to acknowledge the race of her trouble students. So when she talks about an incident, I ask her, ‘was the student white’? To which she grudgingly says, ‘no’.
      She used to teach at a Catholic school and loved her job. She left to work for the Buffalo public school system (at more than double the pay) and now she counts the days to her retirement.

      • bilderbuster

        You must do this as often as possible & remind yourself that for her to acknowledge this is for her own good.

      • withcaution

        “Double the pay!” Yea, nearly no one I talk to realizes just how much teachers make in all the leftist states. A BA with 10 years tenure is earning $82,000 plus another $39,000 for an insane benefits package in my state. All for a contractually mandated work load not to exceed 945 hours. That includes 182 hours to grade papers. That’s $128 an hour to misinform our kids.

        • Beetlejuice

          If the job is so lucrative, why don’t YOU do it.

          Ever been in a black school? $128 is not nearly enough and that’s why black schools have such serious staffing problems.

    • dd121

      At AmRen these taboos get spoken publically.

      • Beetlejuice

        No, they don’t.

    • GOD

      That would include me. I experienced REALITY. I emailed the author with my thoughts, which included asking her if she ever taught in a public school before. Let’s see if she responds. In the meantime, check out the author and the “professor” who developed the assessment. Holy Liberals Batman! No laughing now!

      • Rhialto

        Note that these are pictures of two different organisms; not before and after “gender reassignment” of the same specimen.

      • bilderbuster

        I know that look!

        • Whitetrashgang

          Yes once again the Amish have tricked us, when will we ever learn.

        • Max Krakah

          the last three letters are correct, and the first letters are not “IR”

      • Beetlejuice

        That’s the same person, ugly before and after sex reassignment surgery.

    • Yancy Derringer

      I’ve just come from reading three different blog threads on the subject (search something like “do black students misbehave more”) — the consensus of teachers appears to be unanimous, that black students misbehave a great deal more than white students.

      These teachers are none too happy, either, with the Obama/Holder directive to reduce disciplinary measures on black students so they’re more in line with those on white students.

      • LaSantaHermandad

        I totally with you on that part Yancy. My good friend LaSantaHermandad let me use his comment to relive old times. Your post is plenty wise.
        Ista sasasaweh,
        Your faithful friend,

        Pajoo Katewah- Wolf who stands in water.

    • Yale2001

      Exactly. I know MANY teachers and one of my friends is a principal. This is NOT new info. I personally know many that home school their children simply to avoid blacks. Two of our friends started home schooling in the middle of 12th grade. It was sad for everyone that they could not finish with their friends, but blacks absolutely could not keep their hands off them. Since it was always several or different blacks the law could not help; either. We did get an another officer to help police the schools, but they can’t be everywhere.

  • bigone4u

    Blacks can’t learn and they can’t behave. Teachers are now put in the position of being unarmed, disempowered prison guards. Expect more raped and murdered young women like the lovely young woman in Massachusetts who was found dead and raped in the ladies room last month. No wonder teachers leave the profession in droves. Sadly, some leave in a body bag.

    • newscomments70

      We knew a teacher, a family friend, who lived through Boston’s forced bussing in the 70s. She was gang-raped by her 15 year old black students. She was not young and attractive though, she was 62 years old.

  • John Smith

    They are barfing up this nonsense as if each incident subject to a possible suspension exists in a vacuum.

    When comparing suspension rates for blacks vs. whites, maybe the foolish anti-white media creatures should factor in PAST BEHAVIOR of suspended students.

    Say a student is involved in an altercation. Scenario A – the student has no previous discipline record. Scenario B – the student has had multiple disciplinary incidents. Is a student in scenario A and B going to be disciplined the same? Of course not!

    You simply cannot win with blacks. Collectively, we simply CANNOT co-exist with them. This has become increasingly obvious on a daily basis since May 1954.

    • bilderbuster

      The Anti-White media creatures know exactly what they’re factoring.

      • QuinnTheEskimo9

        You are right that this is, bottom line, anti-white, not pro-black. Feral black criminals are allowed to roam freely amongst whites and assault us and our little children, while the media ignore, excuse and rationalize their criminality, because it is directed at whites.

        More proof of the war on whites.

  • baldowl

    “Studies have found no support for the hypothesis that black students misbehave more often,” said Angela Ciolfi. Well then, no studies have ever been conducted in any of the schools I or anyone I know has every attended, because the most disruptive, vulgar, and violent “students” in any public school class I ever took were ALWAYS black.
    Additionally surprising: only twice as many blacks as whites suspended? I know from experience that black behavior is only getting worse, so I take that to mean that more white students are behaving like savages, too.

    • JDInSanD

      The black suspension would be even higher except they’re already spending so much time in suspension that they’re not in school to cause even more problems.

      Which is kind of like saying the murder rate is lower because their are so many murderers in prison.

    • Nathanwartooth

      I have emailed her asking her for the links to the studies so I can see what she is talking about.

      Oh and it says that Angela was the one who wrote the story, so she quoted herself. That would be like Jared going:

      “It has been found that blacks commit more crimes than whites”, says Jared Taylor.

      • robinbishop34

        “I just laughed out loud reading your comment,” said Robin.

      • Yancy Derringer

        You’re right — Angela Ciolfi the writer quotes Angela Ciolfi the advocate. Question: how hard did Angela press Angela to support her claims? And is Angela sure she quoted Angela accurately?

        The original article is the same as the version here.

  • Oldcorporal

    Yet another playing of the race card. Black males, on average, are the most disruptive of all students in U.S. schools, and the most likely to turn to violence. This is yet another attempt to deny that, or explain it away.

  • DonReynolds

    Sure there is proof that black males misbehave more than white males……they are twice as likely to be suspended from school. But they get a pass, because it should be four or five times more likely, but because they are black…..we overlook crap that would get a white boy suspended.

  • APaige

    “Studies have found no support for the hypothesis that black students misbehave more often”,-it is not an ‘educated guess’ that blacks misbehave-it is a fact.

  • shawnmer

    “Studies have found no support for the hypothesis that black students misbehave more often,”

    And when did you order teachers to stop collecting data on that, maam? If you expect me to believe they have perfect and angelic conduct the 1st 12 years of their life, then suddenly and inexplicably, decide to be the 13% of the population who commits half of all crime, you’re smoking rope.

  • JohnEngelman

    “Studies have found no support for the hypothesis that black students misbehave more often,” said Angela Ciolfi.

    – Angela Ciolfi, UVA Today, December 18, 2013

    Those studies were as ineffective as black efforts to study for a calculus exam.

  • sbuffalonative

    I did a search of Mr. Dewey Cornell and discovered he’s white. So you know where his bias lies, here are two books he wrote:

    School Violence: Fears Versus Facts and Guidelines for Responding to Student Threats of Violence.

    Apparently, school violence is only a fear and not a fact while at the same time, teachers need guidelines to respond to ‘imaged’ fears of threats and violence.

    • QuinnTheEskimo9

      I’m sure those two books will join Bill Ayers’ books as required reading in teachers colleges all over the country

  • curri

    The lies are getting more and more absurd. The US today is like the Brezhnev era of the USSR.

    • dd121

      I think more like Stalinists.

      • QuinnTheEskimo9

        Russians know what to do with violent criminals.

  • Zaporizhian Sich

    Only twice as often as whites? This can only mean that blacks get away with anything short of very serious offences, and whites are held hyper-accountable for their behavior.

    • Garrett Brown

      More like 3-4 times. For every white kid that got in trouble and sent our there were 5-6 blacks getting in trouble as well. The difference would be the majority of teachers were liberal and took it easy on the blacks.

    • 1stworlder

      Must suck to get suspended for chewing gum and have to walk past a black raping someone in a stairwell.

  • OhWow

    Just a totally wild guess: maybe blacks and whites don’t act the same.

  • Fighting_Northern_Spirit

    I’d love to see these “studies” that show blacks act up less and are punished more for minor infractions. No doubt they’re printed on paper made of unicorn farts.

    • dd121

      I’m forming this mental image of unicorns and their farts. It just faded.

  • Spartacus


    • QuinnTheEskimo9

      Good job Spartacus. Left up for 14 hours, that must be a new record for one of your (fantastic) images. Keep it up.

    • LaSantaHermandad

      You lose attention you die!!!
      Avoid the Blacks!
      ¡Evite los prietos!
      Evité las noirs,
      Evitare i neri!
      Vermeiden Sie die Schwarze Menschen!
      God don’t ya love the European Languages?!

  • Garrett Brown

    I went to William Fleming in southwest VA. I highly regret it.

    • Who Me?

      Few white children have any choice in which high school they would like to try to survive for 4 years. Unless your parents had the foresight and the wherewithal to move to a neighborhood with good schools or enroll you in a private school, you went where you were told. If it was an “urban” public school, you simply lived through 4 years of terror and came out with PTSD, ulcers, or some other stress-related ailment that lay like a ticking time-bomb in you system forever after.

      • Garrett Brown

        I had a choice and made one of the worst decisions of my life. Before I became a realist I just wanted to be with friends. I was a dumb kid. I definitely learned my lesson.

        • sbuffalonative

          Don’t blame yourself. You were a victim of ‘progressive’ brainwashing. ‘Progressives’ know whites are by nature trusting and nice and they exploit these traits. You’re not the first, last, or only one. Think of AR as the AA of progressive detox.

          • Garrett Brown

            I and a few others grew up. I unfortunately can say the high majority did not. As you said, I think most whites do not wake up because of the kindness in their heart, not their level of intelligence.

  • It also finds that most black students are being suspended for relatively minor misbehavior, such as being loud or disruptive in class.

    Being loud or disruptive …. LMAO. More like answering teacher “Fuh dat”.
    And then theft, rape, and assault.

    • Yancy Derringer

      Besides, being disruptive in class — shutting the process down — is hardly minor.

      • Alexandra1973

        I’d be looking at ways white kids are disruptive in class vs. ways black kids are disruptive.

        I bet there’d be a huge difference!

  • libertarian1234

    “Study: Va. Schools Suspend Black Male Students at Twice the Rate of White Males”
    Another bogus study by a group of left wing crazies.

    Blacks commit infractions and disruptions at FAR MORE than twice the white rate. Probably Obama’s mandate to stop expelling disruptive, trouble-making blacks went into effect before this study was made or the schools are already giving preferential treatment to blacks, so their punishment rate has been reduced.

    But whatever they’re trying to lie about now is going to wind up biting them on the azz, because this kind of false information only encourages these black miscreants to behave even worse.

    And the deterioration continues on schedule.

  • c684570

    “Studies have found no support for the hypothesis that black students misbehave more often,”

    Is this Bizarro World?

    “In fact, racial disparities in suspension rates have raised increasing concern nationally because the data shows just the opposite – that black students are more likely to be suspended for more subjective and less serious reasons.”

    Yeah, because violent assault is “less serious”, right?

    • QuinnTheEskimo9

      Everything has been downgraded. Violent assaults by blacks are now considered minor disagreements or small schoolyard fights which “happen in all schools,” with both parties being blamed equally, or more so if the victim is non-black.

  • bubo

    Just another lie. Everyone that’s spent one day in racially mixed public schools knows damn well that blacks misbehave a multitude of 10 above any other race.

  • Luca

    Beware of liberal writings and studies. When a liberal says: “It also finds that most black students are being suspended for relatively minor misbehavior, such as being loud or disruptive in class.”, take notice that it does not mention if the “minor misbehaving” entailed numerous chances or warnings and whether or not the occurrences of the same minor offense happened over and over. In other words, did the teachers have to ask the student to calm down on 15 occasions? Did the minor disruptive behavior include threats of violence? Did the “loudness” include profanity?

    More than likely the study only looked at the immediate offense for suspension and not the circumstantial/supporting evidence leading up to it.

    Just today, I was in a doctor’s office and the three blacks in the waiting were completely oblivious to all concepts of courtesy and quiet, polite conversation. Everyone within a 50 yard radius could hear their ebonics-filled conversations and animated laughing.

    You would have thought they were at a comedy club or party rather than a doctor’s office. Then, God forbid you should ask them to be civil.

    The same thing happens in the classroom.

    • QuinnTheEskimo9

      What they do is talk to the kid and his mother, never the teachers, counselors or principals. The violent criminal says the teacher is racist and he “didn’t to nuffin.” Mother says teacher is racist and picks on her son, who is really an A student, because he is black. Researchers take copious notes and their studies dutifully report that blacks are being suspended by racist schools. Newspapers pick this up and it becomes the prevailing wisdom that the only reason blacks are suspended is due to entrenched racism against blacks.

  • Whirlwinder

    These “studies” were conducted by government. Highly unlikely that they would be biased towards blacks. This is more governmentspeak. Garbage.

  • fuzzypook

    I went to an all white elementary school in the 60’s. I was introduced to the bantu in jr. high school, and subjected to even more of them in high school. School is where I learned race realism.

    • Same here, but 20 years later. And my schools were in no way blackened.
      I taught one a lesson one day. Was never bothered again.

      • fuzzypook

        I myself took down one black bitch. It was in 8th grade science class. After class let out. I was 5′ tall but stronger that that bantu realized. I was always athletic and I had gotten pretty strong from riding my bike with a huge satchel full of newspapers and heaving them onto people’s porches. When that loud mouth bantu went for me I quickly got her in a headlock and flung her around the room, knocking over desks as we scrapped. That black bitch and her friends never bothered me again.

        • fuzzypook

          By the way, I’m a girl.

  • Sick of it

    “Studies have found no support for the hypothesis that black students misbehave more often,”

    Studies authored by madmen and morons perhaps. I’ve seen black kids bust out into violent fights in the middle of the school day during lunch. In the middle of class. How do you stop them when you’ll get fired, arrested and sued for doing anything?

    • IstvanIN

      I knew a teacher who got fired for stopping two bucks from beating the life out of a shrimpie Puerto Rican kid.

  • DailyKenn

    Those of us who attended black schools are shocked! TEN TIMES the rate would still be too generous.

  • NotTooSwift

    In 1959, 50% of my high-school class was black. They were totally disruptive. They would fight one another (never bothering us white students, though), disrespect the teachers, talk among themselves, etc. Zero disciplinary action was ever taken. Things got so bad that I quit school after 11th grade and joined the Navy. Remember, this was 1959.

    Paraphrasing the Bible “nothing is new under the sun”, unfortunately, applies to blacks in this case.

  • Ella

    Throw in gangs and you have a disaster in the halls and during lunch period. Some schools do suspend gang signals and dress in the halls. These Black kids have mouths on them that can humiliate both the teachers and students. It damages the learning environment.

  • JohnEngelman

    Public schools with black majorities are nearly always dangerous places where little learning occurs. Whites, Asians, and blacks who try to learn are usually harassed and often beaten up.

    Those who cannot be educated, and who violently interfere with the education of others, should be permanently expelled so that teachers can teach and students can learn.

    What will happen to those who are expelled? The same thing that happens to them anyway. They will end up in prison. The sooner they get there, the longer they stay, and the harsher they are treated the better it will be for decent people of all races.


      “the better it will be for decent people of all races” – I couldn’t agree more, but they are not concerned with decent people of all races. They are concerned with one group of people, and one race. Judging by how often this one group of people are at the center of every and all public concern over the last 50yrs. I would say that as far as our government goes. It appears the only group of people they’ve deemed worthy of their concern is this one, all encompassing group. They must be a truly vital part of our society considering everything our government, backed by Whitey’s tax dollars is so willing to do for them.

      • JohnEngelman

        You are speaking clandestinely of the Jews. They owe their dominance in the United States to their intelligence and to the fact that most Americans accept them, and many including me admire them.

        • QuinnTheEskimo9

          Stop spreading lies. You are wrong again, like you are about so many things.

          It is your OPINION that Jews owe their dominance in the U.S. to…

          “Should Jews be considered Whites?”

          Jews typically do not identify with the people and culture of Christian Europe and its offshoots; traditional Jewish attitudes conceptualize Judaism as separate from White, Christian society; partly because of their lack of identification with non-White Christian culture, Jewish groups have led the campaign to remove Christianity from the public square

          There is a long history of very mainstream Jewish activism and identity that sees Christian Europe as an evil outgroup responsible for a long history of persecuting Jews; an important aspect of Jewish self-conception in America.

          Jews are a relatively powerful group that has often been in competition with non-Jewish Europeans

          Jewish ethnic activism typically excludes non-Jewish Whites and favors Jews, as in the appointment of Elena Kagan and the Jewish campaign to increase Jewish enrollment in Ivy League universities.

          As a result, the distinction between Jew and non-Jewish White is of considerable real world importance.


    “why hasn’t a rapper or sports star started a supermarket chain” – Why bother trying to provide anything to their people when they know that the government, flushed with Whitey’s tax dollars. Is just one claim of racism away from stepping in to do for them, what we do for ourselves.

    Just another day in the land of the the late great United States if America.

  • Chasmania

    Virginia Student Threat Assessment Guidelines sounds like it should it should instead be titled ‘How to Make Excuses for Racial Minorities Misbehaviour’. I’m sure it reads like some Orwellian inspired thought guide that only state sponsored drones could or would tolerate.

    • robinbishop34

      They just keep moving the goalposts. Eventually black on white rape will be called justifiable reparations relations.

  • De’Ontavious Jizzaiah Jones

    Until recently, I worked for a southern state dept of children and families as an atty. There is great pressure being put on the DCF attys to call state attys to try to talk them into reducing criminal charges against the feral child criminals in state custody (after removal from primarily the mothers custody as usually missing fathers) and sending case to some BS diversion program. I read a police report my last week there where a black male at a primarily black charter school became loud and physically disruptive. He repeatedly told teachers and the black principal to go f themsves and pushed them and the contracted school security officer. Then other students poured out of classrooms to get involved. Principal’s sworn statement said the students then “became impossible to control.” She called police. The original black feral fought with police and was arrested. Feral’s mother then arrived at school and first thing she did was to start accusing security officer and police of brutality on her feral child. This is the uncivilized environment that exists in schools today. Yet, unless you work in an area that regularly accords you direct insight or read AMREN, you would never know by reading articles like this that cover up the truth and present false argument that there must be racism bc black males are being “disproportionately” punished through suspension, expulsion. This article includes blatant lie in a quote that it is not true that black behavior is worse than the white kids. That is a LIE and everyone on this site knows it.

    • robinbishop34

      “That is a LIE and everyone on this site knows it.”

      Everyone here knows it but unfortunately there are a lot of people out there who will swallow this nonsense wholesale.

  • De’Ontavious Jizzaiah Jones

    Just to clarify my comment – the child criminals in DCF cases in the county I worked in were majority black.

  • Reverend Bacon

    Of course no one believes that blacks misbehave at the same rates. They just want the bar to be lowered, so that a large portion of the offenses that blacks commit and white kids don’t, are no longer called offenses.

    This is essentially Obama’s Executive Order called “White House Initiative on Educational Excellence for African Americans.” You should look it up, it’s a travesty.

    • Yancy Derringer

      It is a travesty. It’s blatantly racist — pro-black, anti-white.

    • GeneticsareDestiny

      Liberals are finally, clandestinely admitting that they can’t think of any way to really lower the black misbehavior/crime rate. But they also cannot tolerate any disparities between races (unless it favors non-whites over whites), so they’re doing the only thing possible to “close” the gap.

      The only way to do it is to define most of the misbehavior of blacks as being acceptable, so that’s the road they’re taking.

  • newscomments70

    I like the idea of forcing them to work for their food…no table football, they should be mopping floors and scrubbing toilets.

  • Bill_der_Berg

    “t also finds that most black students are being suspended for relatively minor misbehavior, such as being loud or disruptive in class.”

    No surprises there. Disruptive behaviour makes teaching impossible.

    • Reverend Bacon

      They talk loud at movies too.

  • Anon

    Yeah, well, George Carlin was well paid for his entire life to negrify white culture through his “comedy”.. Toward the end, he was quite fond of bitching about how far we’ve fallen….amazing considering the heavy hand he had in making it happen.

    • LaSantaHermandad

      I totally agree with you on that point but vis a vis the Black kids in the White school, he was spot on!

  • Anon

    The main point of the article is not to push the ridiculous notion home that blacks a just the same as white with regard to incidents of discipline. That is obviously not true and the article wants you to argue this as it simply lies.

    The real issue here is it has subtly lumped all discipline problems under one category in order to hide the fact that this term means something completely different with whites than blacks.

    Whites – chewing gum, looking out the window, whispering to friend, doodling, reading something unrelated to class

    Blacks – jumping up and kicking desk across the room, playing the knockout game, flashing gang signs, flashing guns and knives, threatening to rape the (male or female) teacher after class, openly smoking crack in class, openly dealing drugs in class, leaving the room and/or entering the room at random, if they have that class or no, raping a student in the bathroom, raping a teacher in the bathroom, then slitting her throat and dragging her down to the woods outside to pose her dead body with a stick violating her vagina (in the news recently), running gun battles in the hallways.

    Well….you get the point. The two issues are in no way relevant. At minimum, blacks should not be allowed in school. But, quite frankly, each of those serious, serious crimes they are trying to list under discipline issues are hanging offenses.

  • Juan Outtamany

    Anyone that has suffered through public schools since 1970 knows the truth.

    • Alexandra1973

      I went to school in the Detroit area. Really diverse. Students self-segregated; everyone generally left each other alone.

      But I do recall this one incident in first grade, at lunch. This black kid (I think he may have been mulatto, he’s not coal-black) asked me if he could have something out of my lunch, and I said “no.” His reply? “You stingy!” Yep, gibsmedat. And of course he’s going around blabbing to other kids about how “stingy” I was.

      At home I asked my mom if I was being stingy, and she said no, she made lunches for me, not for every kid in the school!

      This was in 1979-80. When I was in school it was pretty much “you stay out of my face and I’ll stay out of yours.”

      I know it doesn’t always work that way–sometimes they’ll just get in your face without any provocation. Never had that happen to me. Maybe that’s why my awakening took a bit longer.

  • Fr. John+

    “Studies have found no support for the hypothesis that black students misbehave more often.”

    Ever hear of crime stats, that have PROVEN blacks commit TEN TIMES more serious crimes than Whites? Houston, I think we have a problem here. Like willful blindness, when it comes to the reality of race, and the ‘otherness’ of those not Caucasoid.

  • Joe Sewell

    I’m reminded of the school system Treyvon Martin attended. Criminality was reclassified as ‘non criminality’; disruptive, destructive behavior was reclassified as ‘good, constructive behavior’. Poor grades were reclassified as ‘good grades’ The south Florida school district became a ‘model district’ overnight and we know the rest of the story. Thinking this is happening all over the U.S..

    • jane johnson

      The district you are referring to is Miami-Dade, and you are correct about all the reclassifications and the resulting Potemkin model district. Now, for the rest of the story: the administrator responsible for that miraculous transformation is one Nicolai Vitti. He has held such titles as Chief Academic Officer, Assistant Superintendent of the Educational Transformation Office, and, my personal favorite, Lead Director for Differentiated Accountability, among others. This versatile individual’s latest title is Superintendent of Duval County Public Schools, and his latest claim to fame was coming out in favor of changing the name of Nathan Bedford Forrest High School, and lavishly praising the school board when their unanimous vote made it happen. Beware if this man comes to your town.

      • GeneticsareDestiny

        “Lead Director for Differentiated Accountability”

        This is the most hilarious thing I’ve read all day. They’re not even trying to hide what they’re doing here.

        • jane johnson

          That’s why it’s my favorite, GD. On a side note, we have a contractor in town who named his business “Watergate Paint Company”, and their slogan is We cover up anything. Kind of reminds me of Mr. Vitti. He’s only been in Duval County a little over a year, and already we have no more Forrest High, and no more failing schools. The guy’s a regular magician when it comes to making inconvenient things disappear.

        • jane johnson

          Here’s a photo of him and his family:

      • Katherine McChesney

        Nicolai Vitti….sounds like a servant of the Vatican in Catholic country.

      • Joe Sewell

        I’m a product of the Duval County School System – graduated in the early ’70s. A real shame as Vitti’s initiatives only benefit the khazar conspiracy.

  • QuinnTheEskimo9

    Too bad we’ve become such sheeple to the point where we’re forced to move. In the old days, that black criminal, despite his young age, would have disappeared, no one in the neighborhood would have seen a thing, the cops wouldn’t pursue it and one more violent black would have been eliminated.

  • QuinnTheEskimo9

    Egomania and hubris because she knows no one will call her on it.

  • Max Krakah

    Sooner or later the lies liberals live under will just be too great and they will have to admit the truth. That truth is that blacks are violent creatures with no self control and they are extremely narcissistic. Without the threat of immediate and severe punishment, they simply will not act like humans. They are disruptive to human education and humans should not be burdened with them. They are disruptive to human societies and human should not be burdened with them. Segregation, which liberals practice with their exclusive communities, should be allowed for all humans. Liberals will have to admit someday that while they may preach integration and all that rotgut, the way they live is the exact opposite.

    • MartelC

      lies liberals live under will just be too great
      I’d like to believe you but liberals are so far gone that even being ‘mugged by reality (and beaten)’, literally, has no effect.

      • jane johnson


        • MartelC

          There’s an old saying, a neocon is a liberal who’s been mugged by reality. (a quip off of the crime-laden 1970s in New York City)
          But that is not so – many a liberal victim of the ‘knock out game’ will claim race has nothing to do with it.

  • MartelC

    How long can a system built on lies last? Many of us think liberals will come around, I don’t think they ever will – after all, most of them are weak minded conformists who know those in power WANT us to believe these things, so they must..

    It’s funny to see people in liberal strong holds like New York and San Fran or your sundry NPR listener, think they are some how ‘edgy’ and ‘daring’ for being liberal… as if the establishment are WASPs wearing mink lined ties, scuffing at ‘progressives’

    • Alec Smart

      Believe it or not, but as much as there are lots of liberals in New York City, white liberals are very well aware of the differences between blacks and whites. Some are in denial, but many are not.

      The voting in this town is left leaning mainly due to the high nonwhite populations, and high jewish populations.

      But a higher number of whites have low opinions of nonwhites. I think this is an effect of being around them all the time.

      Now younger generations that don’t remember how bad crime was in the 1980s are less likely to have negative opinions of blacks, but sooner or later either they or someone they know has their iphone stolen by a group of pack animal black teenagers. That will change your opinion of blacks in a nanosecond.

      • QuinnTheEskimo9

        DeBlasio’s reign in NY City will bring things back to how they were in the 70s and 80s, an advantage, I supposed, as it will make more race realists, those who survive black crime, that is.

  • Hunter Morrow

    Murder is a hard criminal statistic to fudge. Realistically there are two ways to fudge it:
    Downgrade the severity of the charge or deliberately try not to “solve” the case. For instance, even though blacks officially commit approximately 50 percent of all murders it is probably low-balled on account of the terrible “unsolved” murder rate in Black cities.

    That being said, it is hard to lie with your damn statistics when there is a body on the groud.

    Blacks 14-24 are 3 percent of the population and 25 to 30 percent of all convicted murderers. They commit crimes at a tremendous rate, especially violent ones.
    There is no felony that I know of that blacks commit at a lower percentage than Whites.
    Collectively, black adults are 30 to 50 times more likely to be felonious than a White
    and these figures may even be understating the disparity.

    Why would the children be any different?

    Now, think who brought these people over on boats to make money. Think who made money in Reconstruction. Think who foisted the NAACP and “Civil Rights” on us.
    Think who writes the curriculum and founded the Department of Education. Think about and you’ll find where the real blame lies.

  • Massif1

    If blacks took Statistics 101 in college instead of African American Studies – Whine, Whine, Whine – they might be able to see a graph in their head of disproportionate crime rates they commit.

    • MartelC

      according to the left, disparate impact is just that – disparate impact – so any statistical difference in black crime, dropout rates, iq test, % passing civil service exams, MUST be the result of racism because all races are equal.

      Yes it’s insanity but we live in insane times.

    • Beetlejuice

      Blacks with an average IQ of 75 could never handle statistics. They cannot master basic math.

  • Kayla91

    When I was in high school, a popular black guy that played basketball was making fun of a girl during class. (Of course, the teacher did nothing.) I told him to leave her alone. He threatened to have me killed, cussed me, called me every name in the book. I go to the office and I hear “oh, Zahkiya is just upset because they lost the game last night.” I got an apology from him, no suspension, no nothing. This was 2009 or 2010.

    • emiledurk16

      The double standard is really sickening.

    • Alexandra1973

      Out of curiosity, where was this school?

      My cousin has a daughter named Kayla who was born in 1991. So I find your moniker rather interesting.

  • crockadoodle6

    One of the thresholds one reaches on the journey of race realism is to ignore what the MSM, government funded ‘studies’, politicians and Hollywood say. Always sanitized, agenda-driven bullshit…ALWAYS.

  • emiledurk16

    This article pulls the liberal magic trick by saying that “yes, black students are suspended twice as often as white students, BUT that’s because black students are suspended for minor infractions whereas white students aren’t, THEREFORE”….well, we know what their conclusion is.

    Threat Assessment Guidelines….Don’t make me laugh.

  • Garrett Brown

    Respect to you for even trying to teach them.

  • GeneticsareDestiny

    “why hasn’t a rapper or sports star started a supermarket chain in the last 30 years to meet the needs of their people and make money while doing it?”

    Because it’s impossible to make money running a store in all-black neighborhoods. You’ll lose so much of your merchandise to theft (both by outside blacks and by your employees, who will necessarily be black, since no white person will work there) that you’ll lose money on your investment.

    There is no profit in running anything other than a liquor store or a payday loan store in these areas (and honestly, I’m not sure how the liquor store owners are doing it; they’re vulnerable to theft too).

    • For the same reason that established big box supermarket chains don’t have many stores in Bell Curve City. You don’t throw good money after bad, the grocery business is notoriously low margin, insurance costs of operating in high crime areas, stealing, grazing, corrupt employees that pass items along without scanning them, and so on.

      How can the liquor stores survive in the ghetto? A combination of higher than usual prices and the fact that whatever street gang owns the block where the store is situated can be relied upon to be de facto store security in exchange for merchandise. How do the payday loan joints do it? Usurious interest rates, at least it would seem usurious to us, but it’s just what the market bears and demands in Bell Curve City.

  • newscomments70

    I was thinking of that when I posted. I live in your area as well.

  • GeneticsareDestiny

    Yes, that’s exactly what happens in schools with lots of blacks. At my school, in any class with three or more blacks, the teacher would have to spend at least 1/4 to 1/2 of all the class time trying to keep them quiet and in their seats, with the amount of wasted time scaling as the number of blacks increased.

    Eventually some of the teachers would give up trying to keep them in their seats and let them roam the classroom at will in a vain attempt to regain some educational time. It didn’t work though, because they’d get more loud when they were allowed to roam.

  • Ograf

    Only twice the rate of White students? Any one day observation of these folks would clearly show the suspensions rightfully should be more like 6 to 8 times the rate of Whites.

  • gemjunior

    Ah, it’s such a treat to have to be asked, yet again, to suspend reality for fantasy and deny the evidence placed in front of my eyes in favor of a study that shows yet again, blacks are being singled out for unfair treatment. Disruptive behavior? Maybe such as shucking and jiving during an important Maff Lecture, or let’s see – running up behind a special need student and punching him in the head? After all, we all did that in high school, right? Right? Although whites are picking up more and more that we are NOT equal in all regards and we aren’t “benefitting” so much from the Great Society (ahem), they do neeI d to see that evidence over and over to really absorb it. And although I am not enjoying it, the negro majority is providing ample evidence with their knockout games and other shines. So when people read this Blarney, these ‘studies’ they will wrinkle their brows in suspicion and eventually start to wonder why the exact opposite of the truth is constantly being pounded into them. That was what started me on my journey – the sort of uncomfortable wondering about why we were always being lied to with the fairy tale of black=good, black=positive, black misbehavior=not their fault, violent black behavior including black rape and black murder although overwhelming in regard to population size = not their fault. I really started to wonder what was up and when I happened onto Amren I was enlightened. And that led to other race-realist sites, books, etc. I had known about stormfront but never went on it because I knew it was Racist and therefore evil. Same with david duke – never! Me, associate with such rabble? Such terrible prejudiced, evil purveyors of HATE? Not me. Now, I see the propaganda is designed to keep whites away precisely for that very reason. Negro fatigue will eventually rear it’s head, trust me. Like “The truth will out”, the case is that “negro fatigue will out”. It can’t remain hidden forever.

  • MikeofAges

    Even when the offenses are equal, the punishment has to relate to the child. I went to school with a lot of black kids. One thing I know is that black kids live to socialize. When you take that away from the kid, you are doing something that is going make an impression on him, or her. For a white kid, having to stay after school, having the parents called in for a conference or being taken out of an activity might accomplish the necessary effect.

    Who’s to say suspension is worse than any other punishment?

  • Katherine McChesney

    Stinko de Mayo…..LOL

  • David Ashton

    Having taught in both white and multi-racial schools I can assure those whose ignorance of modern classroom behaviour doesn’t inhibit them from comment that low-level disruption can ruin lessons. In Britain, Jamaican boys are worse in ability and behaviour than Jamaican girls, but they can both “take offence” and claim “racism” quite readily; a low-level sign of hostility is teeth-sucking or turning the back. Those who refuse to note racial or cultural variations, not only in education, are adept at employing phrases like “no convincing evidence” rather than assess information objectively, whereas they will quite rapidly jump at fraudulent excuses like “systemic racism” or “teacher prejudice” or “poor nutrition” or “low expectations” or “anglocentric curricula”, etc.

    • They do it there too, the teeth sucking? It must be a common trait among west African blacks everywhere.

      I’ve noticed that at least here, among blacks, boys and men do it more often than girls and women, and especially androgynous, effeminate and questionably homosexual boys men do it in turn more.

  • MikeofAges

    In most of the history of organized society, boys went into apprenticeship or started working at the age of 14, sometimes younger. It would be a serious heresy in our society to say that some kid should end their education at eighth grade, but, for a select some, it might be the best choice. If we had work, of course. Which we don’t.

  • Katherine McChesney

    American troops engage in massive rape of foreign women during war.

  • Katherine McChesney

    at Mass???

    I find that laughable.

  • Katherine McChesney

    In the sixties, H. Rap Brown came to Nashville. Blacks were burning north Nashville. I knew a National Guard soldier who was sent to block the blacks from rioting. He said a big buck N*gg*er yelled out to them “You honkeys think you’re so smart for watching us. You’re here while our brothas are out raping your women.” The Guard had unloaded guns. If not our guys would have shot him dead.

  • Pro_Whitey

    Yes, I recall that federal judges concluded that it was OK for the school to suspend them because of the threat of a possible riot. The same group of judges says that it is unacceptable for the California prison system to segregate prisoners by race in a lockdown situation, usually touched off by a riot or one about to happen. When I see stuff like that, it strikes me that there is no real law anymore.

  • LaSantaHermandad

    The Progressive Schmucks have destroyed the educational system.
    For years they have forced us to go to school with and tolerate the predations of the Wilde Chaim.

  • Troyboy

    When I went to school the blacks and whites stood together against the Mexicans , I was in California schools then , now they are all against each other .

  • Yale2001

    “Studies have found no support for the hypothesis that black students misbehave more often,” said Angela Ciolfi…………….. We’ll then the study is flawed. I have friends that are teacher (ones a principal), I often substitute, and I have children in school. All of us realize and know that blacks misbehave more often and have less control. They are harder to teach and more disruptive. The opposite is definitely true with discipline. We actually expect more out of our white kids and tolerate less misbehavior from them. If I was to send some of our black kids to the office every time they were disruptive, they would never be in class. Why don’t these people just ask the kids.

    • DiversityIsDeath

      Left wing trickery. How do the researchers define “misbehave”? Are these researchers equating chewing gum in class with threatening to kill the teacher? The researchers tallied up all the incidents of white kids committing this little infraction, and that little infraction, and it added up to similar number of incidents as negroes assaulting and raping and gangbanging and selling drugs, and then the researchers declare “Oh no, negroes don’t misbehave any more than white kids do.” Cute.