Posted on December 3, 2009

Immigration Enforcement–A Jobs Program

Mark Krikorian, National Review, December 3, 2009


Restricting immigration is fundamentally different from restricting trade in two ways, one theoretical, one practical. First, people are not things–in addition to being labor inputs, they also happen to be people. This isn’t a new insight, but one that apparently requires repeating. The general principle, unrelated to immigration, was articulated by Peter Drucker when, in The Practice of Management, he recommended “consideration of the human resource as human beings having, unlike any other resource, personality, citizenship, control over whether they work, how much and how well . . .” Henry Ford is said to have expressed the businessman’s frustration at this, asking “Why is it every time I ask for a pair of hands, they come with a person attached?”

In the immigration context, Teddy Roosevelt made the same point: “Never under any condition should this nation look at an immigrant as primarily a labor unit.” Economists have drawn the same conclusion: Henry Simons, the pioneer advocate of the benefits of free-market economics at the University of Chicago, wrote in 1948 that “to insist that a free trade program is logically or practically incomplete without free migration is either disingenuous or stupid. Free trade may and should raise living standards everywhere. . . . Free immigration would level standards, perhaps without raising them anywhere.” Likewise, libertarian economist Hans-Hermann Hoppe has written that “free trade and restricted immigration are not only perfectly consistent, but even mutually reinforcing policies.”


So, specifically at a time of high unemployment when the economy is losing jobs, enforcement of immigration law is an immediate, low-cost jobs program–at least for Americans and legal immigrants, who are the only ones our government is authorized to be concerned about. There are twice as many unemployed Americans as there are employed illegal aliens, and while jobs aren’t just lollipops you take away from one person and give to another, vigorous enforcement could easily open up a quarter-million or half-million jobs held by illegal aliens in no time.


Comments are closed.