Herndon To Shut Down Center For Day Laborers

Bill Turque, Washington Post, September 6, 2007

The Town of Herndon announced yesterday that it would close its 21-month-old day-laborer center next week instead of complying with a judge’s ruling that the site must be open to all residents, including those who might be illegal immigrants.

{snip}

Herndon’s experience with the day-laborer center was a bellwether for towns across the country wrestling with national immigration issues. As other jurisdictions try to pass measures targeting illegal immigrants, yesterday’s actions in Herndon indicate that courts, and not legislators, might have the ultimate say.

DeBenedittis said that the town has other means at its disposal, such as zoning and traffic ordinances, to accomplish its goals.

“There is no longer a need for the town to support a regulated day-labor site,” he said.

Immigrant advocates said yesterday that after the center closes Sept. 14, they expect a return to the chaotic morning scenes in locations such as the 7-Eleven on Herndon’s main street, where scores of laborers gathered to try to find work, many seeking construction jobs along the busy Dulles International Airport corridor.

{snip}

The town’s plan began to collapse last year when a Reston man, Stephen A. Thomas, ticketed for hiring a laborer in the parking lot of the Elden Street 7-Eleven, challenged the law on First Amendment grounds.

A district court found in favor of the town, but Fairfax Circuit Court Judge Leslie Alden ruled for Thomas on Aug. 29. Alden said the anti-solicitation ordinance fell short not only on First Amendment grounds but also under the equal protection requirements of the 14th Amendment. She said the Herndon center was not sufficient to make up for the ban on job solicitation because the town intended to bar illegal immigrants from the site. Alden said the Supreme Court has ruled that the equal protection provision applies to noncitizens as well.

Alden’s ruling left DeBenedittis and the Town Council in a dilemma. An appeal could take months, even years. With no one available to operate the center according to its wishes, the town would have to take over the facility. But to preserve the anti-solicitation ordinance, the town would have to open the center to those who might be in the country illegally—violating a core campaign promise.

On Tuesday night, DeBenedittis and the council decided to pull the plug on the center. DeBenedittis said the town would try to keep informal job sites from popping up by relying on zoning and traffic ordinances.

{snip}

Ann Null, a council member who opposed opening the center before she retired in 2005, said she hoped its closing would induce illegal residents in the town to leave the country.

“There’s a construction boom in Panama,” she said. “They can find jobs in a country where they don’t have to learn the language.”

Topics:

Share This

We welcome comments that add information or perspective, and we encourage polite debate. If you log in with a social media account, your comment should appear immediately. If you prefer to remain anonymous, you may comment as a guest, using a name and an e-mail address of convenience. Your comment will be moderated.

Comments are closed.