Hercules Student Recants Bathroom Sex Attack Story

Kurtis Alexander and Henry K. Lee, San Francisco Chronicle, March 5, 2014

A 15-year-old transgender teen admitted to police Tuesday that he made up a story about being sexually assaulted a day earlier in the boys bathroom at Hercules Middle High School, authorities said.

The boy acknowledged making the false report–which raised alarm at the school and around the Bay Area–after investigators told him that the evidence gathered in the case didn’t corroborate his story, said Hercules police Detective Connie Van Putten.


The boy’s original report had raised concerns on campus, in part because of a previous incident in which another transgender student was involved in a fight on campus in November.

Police have closed what they initially considered a hate-crime investigation and are considering whether the teenager will face criminal charges for filing a false police report, Van Putten said.

The student, who identifies as male, had reported being shoved into a bathroom stall by three male juveniles he didn’t recognize at about 11 a.m. Monday and physically and sexually assaulted, police said. {snip}



Share This

We welcome comments that add information or perspective, and we encourage polite debate. If you log in with a social media account, your comment should appear immediately. If you prefer to remain anonymous, you may comment as a guest, using a name and an e-mail address of convenience. Your comment will be moderated.
  • I guess this is more along the lines of, “Whatchya Doin, Tranny?” rather than “Whatchya Doin, Rabbi?”

    But the template is the same.

    • 1stworlder

      They really should charge hate crime hoaxes as the maximum the hoax could have been.

      • Beetlejuice

        If a few of these merry pranksters were punished harshly, financially as well as serving some well-deserved hard time, as they should be, and the cases publicized far and wide by the press, these hoaxes would stop

  • BonV.Vant

    This is the updated version of “Birth of a Nation”. This time it is a crazy black transexual that makes the false rape claim.

  • Does “he” have a vagina? Is that what I’m reading? If so, “he” is crazy as a loon and should be treated as such. But in our brave new world, Obama will call him on national TV (no, not transvestite, but television) and give him the Congressional Medal of Honor or something. What a sick country the USA has become.

    • Oil Can Harry

      This is apparently a girl who “identifies as” (pretends to be) a boy, like Chaz Bono.

      So first she demands the right to use the men’s room then makes up a phony sex attack when given access to it.

      • So CAL Snowman

        Hey if you aren’t a “victim” in 21st century Obamerica, you aren’t trying.

        • Beetlejuice

          Except for whites. We will never be seen as victims of anything or anyone, only the victimizers. Holder even said that Hate Crimes laws do not cover whites.

          • GeneticsareDestiny

            Well, whites can be victims nowadays, but only if they’re:
            1. Transgender or
            2. Gay/lesbian/bisexual or
            3. Female

            Even white liberal men can get in on the hate crime hoaxes if they pretend to be a woman. It shoots them right up through the ranks of the progressive stack to the #2 spot, behind blacks.

      • One of the left’s favorite demands is gender-neutral restrooms, a concept that seems deliberately designed to facilitate this sort of vicious hoax.

    • Puggg

      Or worse than that, try to start wars against countries that don’t respect the “rights” of trannies.

  • IstvanIN

    The police need to start charging these people, like this person, Crystal Magnum, and everyone else who makes blatantly false allegations and police reports. People lives can be ruined by this garbage.

    • WR_the_realist

      It is already a crime to file a false police report but somehow this law is never enforced when a member of a protected group commits a hate crime hoax.

      • This is actually a felony and not a misdemeanor. If you lie to investigators about a misdemeanor, it’s misdemeanor “false reporting”. If you lie to investigators about a felony – like sexual assault – it’s instantly felony “obstruction of justice”.

        The DA’s office could nail this floon to the proverbial wall if they wanted.

        • Beetlejuice

          I’m sure the SPLC will provide a high-priced, pro bono lawyer to defend the tranny.

      • Beetlejuice

        Exactly nothing happened to Crystal Magnum, a horrid black who thought it was ok to lie about being raped and literally destroyed the lives of those Duke boys. She should have been handed the same sentence that would have been handed to them if they’d done what she, 88 members of the Duke faculty, lefties across the country and the local DA Nifong claimed they’d done and gotten life without parole.

        • Who Me?

          She’s now in prison for a long term, I don’t know if it’s life or not. She flipped out, tried to kill her boyfriend, set her apartment on fire with her kids inside and a whole bunch of other TNB.

        • Katherine McChesney

          She was the accuser but I believe it was Duke Univ. that destroyed the lives of those boys but not standing behind them in the investigation. They let a slovenly black Whore influence them.

  • Einsatzgrenadier

    That transgendered freak belongs in a mental hospital, not on the streets of America where “it” can terrorize average white citizens going about their daily business. “It” should also undergo compulsory sterilization to prevent “it” from spreading “its” DNA.

    • So CAL Snowman

      I’m so glad the USA won WW2 to make the world safe for transgender individuals. What a joke this nation has become.

  • Guest

    I don’t get it. Is the asexual freak male or female? I can never tell when columnists use ambiguous language as to not offend anyone (cowards). Is “it” male or female?

    • GeneticsareDestiny

      This is a biological woman who wants to be a man. It can sometimes be difficult to tell, but a good rule of thumb in news articles about transgendered people is to pay attention to whichever pronouns the reporter uses. If they say “he,” it’s a woman. If they say “she,” it’s a man.

      It’s now un-PC to not use trans people’s “preferred pronouns,” which is why they’ve started doing it automatically.

      And if they say anything like “identifies as a man,” it’s a woman. They wouldn’t have to say “identifies as” if she were a real man.

  • Manaphy

    I don’t get it. Is the asexual freak male or female? I can never tell when columnists use ambiguous language as to not offend anyone (cowards).

    • Michael Mason

      Are you White?
      Or are you Asian?

  • Puggg

    “The (tranny) student identifies as male”

    Which means SHE was born female.

    So she’s pretending to be a he.

    Wait until it’s shower time.

    • At the University of Texas at San Antonio, the trannies have for a decade gotten to use the bathroom of their choice, which led to female employees with vaginas screaming, “Eeek, there’s a penis in the ladies’ room.” The president, Ricardo Romo, was recruiting so many trannies in the name of diversity that the rumors started that he was …. oh, never mind.

      • dukem1

        That’s Romo, as in….?
        (Couldn’t resist.)

      • 1stworlder

        Don’t girls bathrooms not have dividers between the toilets? I thought only gays made holes in the toilet dividers, do dikes shove their tits through the holes? That’s kinda a creepy thought given how they go in groups.

    • BonV.Vant

      who knows with this crowd.

  • 2eRep

    The little freak needs to be institutionalized.

    • Puggg

      I can wrap my little doggy brain around the idea that some men like men, some women like women.

      But I can never accept this “trans” whatever insanity as normal.

      • Beetlejuice

        I don’t care, I just don’t like it shoved in my face as something I should accept as completely normal if not desirable OR made to pay for their sex change operations, which I believe is a part of Obamacare

      • Oil Can Harry

        Puggg, you can tell your owner you now identify as a cat. If he’s a true progressive he’ll buy you Nine Lives and a litter box.

  • haroldcrews

    Frankly I find the use of gender specific pronouns rather confusing with the transgender articles. Some sort of convention needs to be used so that the reader can know the facts exactly.

    • Robert Kelley

      Clearly you haven’t been keeping up. Some of the favorites supposedly are

      ze, zir, sie, hir, singular they, them. The first three sound like Loopy the Loup.

      • haroldcrews

        I’ve never heard of those. I’ve not been keeping up.

  • haroldcrews

    Most of these people are mentally ill and should definitely not be encouraged in their delusion.

  • JSS

    Well we have been assured by the feminist that no women would “ever lie about rape”. So he needs to get a full sex change and try again.

  • Jesse James

    It isn’t polite to make fun of crazy people but good manners don’t require us to take them seriously. Being gender confused is no pass on telling the truth but kids like this do tend to be drama kings and queens.

    • Beetlejuice

      They do real damage when they accuse innocent students of assault, which this confused individual did. I was reminded of the Duke case where innocent boys had their lives destroyed after false accusations of rape. One stated that as he walked across campus, he was greeted by a massive poster of himself on the side of a building with the word “rapist” scrawled across it.
      Those who make false accusations should be severely punished and made to pay restitution to those whose lives they thought it was ok to destroy.

      • When I was an undergrad, the feminist Marxists photographed male students without their permission and then used these photos to produce posters marked “RAPIST” which they then posted around campus. Even more outrageous was the fact that none of these feminazis were ever disciplined in any way for this libel campaign.

        • Norseman

          That history defies belief!

          • They explained that while none of their male subjects was a proven rapist, they “might have been” and that these posters “raised awareness”.

  • r j p

    Mr. Transman …..

    • Diana Moon Glampers

      Great. Now I’m going to be singing that for days.

    • BonV.Vant

      Mr. Transman
      he’s just a queen
      to all of us he is just plain obscene
      mutilated or just a pre-ah-ohp
      will this degeneracy ever come to a stop

      • BonV.Vant

        Mr. Transman
        he doesn’t know
        if he should sit down
        when he has to go
        Did the doctors leave a bad seam
        that prevents him from neatly making a stream

  • BonV.Vant

    I once heard a gay man say that there are no queens like black queens

    • Katherine McChesney

      Somehow black queers disgust me more than White queers. It is strange watching a black behave like a ‘queen’. But, then all homosexual perverts are disgusting.

  • Bon, From the Land of Babble

    Doesn’t matter if it was a hoax, what matters is that it COULD have happened and therefore needs national attention, candlelight vigils, mandated sensitivity for ALL students and federal hate laws against it.

    Think she/he will be charged with filing a false police report??

    If any of those three boys were named and accused, they should sue this mentally ill he/she personally and the school too.

    Mario Trujillo, spokesman for the West Contra Costa Unified School District, said school officials are less concerned with punishing the student than making sure he gets the support he needs.

    Somebody pass me the barf bags!!

  • Spartacus

    Freaks like attention. That’s usually why they’re freaks in the first place .

    • They also constantly demand that the normal elements in society “respect” them in their dysfunctional degeneracy. We will shortly be told that this lunatic was “confused” and that the hoax still “raises awareness”.

      • IstvanIN

        I wouldn’t call someone who really has a huge disconnect between their physical sex and the sex they think they should be a degenerate, I think of it sort of like anorexia. They are one thing but see another. They should, however, receive the kind of pyschological therapy to help them navigate the real world and not the world as they wish it were. This person is a girl, period, and, in school, should be expected to function as a girl, including using the girls restroom. I wouldn’t insist on ribbons and bows, but I feel it is every parent’s obligation to teach their children how to interact with society in a publicly appropriate way, if that makes any sense? We seem to spend a great deal of time trying to get society to accommodate the minority when we should be helping the physical and mental minorities live in the real world.

        We should protect the basic rights of the minority while respecting the wishes of the majority, the second half of my statement seems to be the missing part of this equation.

        None the less the perp should be punished for lying and making a false report, as someone said below. No one should get away with making false allegations, regardless of any problems they may have.

      • Sloppo

        When these hoaxes are discovered and the perpetrator’s lies are found out and exposed to public scrutiny, it does raise awareness. When the hoaxes are successful, they lower awareness.

  • dd121

    The left will never punish these left-agenda hoaxers. Personally, I’d like to take him out in the back alley and cut his b**** off. Oh, wait.

  • 1stworlder

    as a tranny girl she might have tried standing up believing in equality.

  • TXCriollo

    What has the world come to. When i was a kid this crap did not exist, if you were a boy you were a boy a girl you get what im saying. The LGBT people are just something else, this transgendered junk is a mental problem, and we should not accept a mental issue like this by saying o its alright be who you feel like. No we need to take these people and get them help, this is more forced acceptance of something that is wrong

  • Nathanwartooth

    If transgendered people really claim they are a “woman trapped in a mans body” then we should be able to scientifically find this out.

    Women and men both exhibit different traits. We should be able to measure these traits in transgendered people and see where they are in relation to their gender.

    • r j p

      They make prosthesis for these transmen as they are called to wear.
      They allow them to look and pretend like they have a penis.
      Caution: www ftmprosthetics com/about htm

  • BaronBaal

    “He” can see himself as he wants, but other people see “him” for what “he” is- a young girl confused about her sexuality who, in the old days, would have been taken into a dark room and taught why she is a woman…

  • Who Me?

    If this person has gotten to the age of 15 and still hasn’t figured out if it’s a boy or a girl, it needs some assistance. If it’s also making up lies about being assaulted by classmates (a charge that could put them behind bars and mark them as “sex offenders” for life) then it needs to be locked up in some mental institution where it can’t harm others with it’s lies, and it can have it’s own bathroom.

  • his fantasy?

  • DLRisVH

    “It’s a sick world we live in, with sick people!”

  • BonV.Vant

    Did they give her only one napkin or sumfin?

  • That sort of nonsense is why the Olympics does DNA testing. If you have an X and a Y chromosome, you’re a man. If you have two X chromosomes, you’re a woman. It doesn’t matter how you pretend to “self-identify”; DNA is what decides it there.

  • disqus_irCdmAu8It

    It seems as if the vast majority of these so-called attacks on minorities are all self-inflicted. There was a case recently at the Univ of Georgia where Blacks staged email attacks on themselves to generate sympathy. It backfired.

    • When dd21 and I hiked around Palmer Park last week, I admitted to being a genuine racist. I also admitted that Spartacus is one of my favorite posters, so I am probably right-wing even by the standards that obtain here. I didn’t know whether he would be OK or not, so one of the neighbors had Ariadne and Maverick.

      I am 3/16 injun, so I didn’t marry a white woman. I pass for white, but I can track people. The tracks of a woman have toes that point inward, while those produced by a man are in the other direction. People who are running leave different prints than those walking: no heel marks. Bent grass and broken spiderwebs will also help tell which way they came and went. If I have time to make a stick, I can tell how fast they were running and for how long, so this translates into distance; I do the mathematics in my head. I could sometimes smell them when we got close.

      I might be the worst combination of Amerind and Celt, or the best. The jury is still out on that charge. I “pass” but my bloodline – for WN purposes – is polluted forever. I didn’t ask for that.