The city of New York has passed two measures meant to rein in NYPD’s stop-and-frisk program by expanding the definition of racial profiling and enacting a seven-year departmental audit program. Mayor Bloomberg has vowed to veto both.

The New York City Council is seeking to create an independent inspector general with the sole purpose of monitoring the New York Police Department for seven years going forward. Such an inspector would also be charged wtih proposing recommendations on how to improve the department’s operation.

In addition, the council will expand the definition of racial profiling, thus allowing residents who believe they have been a target to sue in state court.

According to Reuters, shortly after the vote Bloomberg promised to veto both measures and force the council to hold another vote to override his veto. Each of the measures passed through the 51-member council with at least 34 votes, which suggests they should have the necessary two-thirds majority to override Bloomberg’s veto.

Both the mayor and New York Police Commissioner Ray Kelly have defended stop-and-frisk, which a federal judge decided was unconstitutional in January 2013, despite criticism of racial profiling, arguing that the frequency in stops attributed to minority neighborhoods are linked to higher crime rates in those city regions.

An analysis by the New York Public Advocate’s office of data provided by the NYPD for 2012 has shown that the likelihood that an African American detained for search would be found in possession of a weapon was half that of a white person.

Data shows that the NYPD uncovered a weapon in one out of every 49 stops of white New Yorkers, while for latinos a weapon was found for one out of every 71 stops, and for African Americans, in one out of 93 stops.

{snip}

Mayor Bloomberg, like his predecessor Rudi Giuliani, has made combating crime a centerpiece of his three terms in office. Since Bloomberg took office in 2002 city data indicates a steady decline in major felony offenses overall, which include murder (including non-negligent manslaughter), rape, robbery, felony assault and burglary. The number of robberies in 2002, for example, were reported to be 27,229, and had dropped to 20,144 by 2012.

The particularly low murder rates for a city the size of New York have been used by mayor Bloomberg and NYPD commissioner Kelly as indications that controversial and unconstitutional police tactics are effective. Still, according to 2012 FBI crime statistics, the city falls somewhere in the middle for all violent offenses–“violent” crime defined as rape, robbery and assault in addition to murder.

In June the Obama administration made waves by extending its support for a monitor to oversee the NYPD’s use of stop-and-frisk. Bloomberg was quick to slam the administration’s move.

“We think that a monitor would be even more disruptive than an IG (inspector general),” Bloomberg said at the time.

“It just makes no sense whatsoever, when lives are on the line, to try to change the rules and hamper the police department from doing their job,” he added. According to the mayor, similar oversight efforts in Philadelphia have hampered efforts to combat crime.

Topics:

Share This

We welcome comments that add information or perspective, and we encourage polite debate. If you log in with a social media account, your comment should appear immediately. If you prefer to remain anonymous, you may comment as a guest, using a name and an e-mail address of convenience. Your comment will be moderated.
  • Please, New Yorkers. Show that you’re at least halfway sane by voting for the only sane candidate for Mayor, Joe Lhota.

    He’s the kind of man who, in a city full of people that pay either way way way too much for condoms or nothing at all for condoms, is the one of the few in his city that pays close to the big box national average for his condoms.

  • IstvanIN

    He likes stop an frisk because it protect his people, that is why Doomberg likes it. Otherwise he would be on board with the city council.

  • The__Bobster

    An analysis by the New York Public Advocate’s office of data provided by the NYPD for 2012 has shown that the likelihood that an African American detained for search would be found in possession of a weapon was half that of a white person.
    ________

    No mention of how many of the guns were legal.

  • bigone4u

    In order to protect a race of criminals, the innocent must suffer and die. The USA has become an insane asylum, with 12 percent of the population able to inflict its paranoid anti-white hate on the other 88 percent and ironically on itself, since most crime is black on black. It doensn’t get much crazier than this.

  • me

    Kurt Russell stars in John Carpenter’s “Escape from New York”(1980’s)
    Any European American tourist that visits NYC in the 21st century will be living in that movie…except no one will try to save Bloomberg. LOL!

  • Sick of it

    Let’s call the “independent inspector general” what it is – A Commissar.

  • Jackryanvb

    Nah.

    NYC demographics have gotten a lot better, city gentrifying, young “hipsters” go in. Asian immigrants, even Muslims are less criminally inclined than underclass Blacks.