Posted on November 14, 2011

Mormon Voters Recalled Pearce over ‘Character,’ Not Immigration

Ben Smith, Politico, November 11, 2011

The recall of Arizona State Senate President Russell Pearce, a Republican who crafted the state’s immigration law, SB 1070, was one of the biggest headlines out of Election Day Tuesday night.

A post-election survey in Pearce’s district found a major erosion among two groups who have typically supported the lawmaker: Mormon (or LDS) voters, and conservatives in general.

The survey, conducted by Project New West with Myers Research, found that Pearce won LDS voters by a 16-point margin–which is “a lot of erosion” from his previous support in that group, said Andrew Myers of Myers Research.

The reasons for this departure were not immigration or a particular political issue, the survey found, but about character.

A full 42 percent of LDS voters said they based their decision on issues like a “personal shortcoming” of Pearce’s or “his dishonesty or corruption,” said Jill Hanauer of Project New West.


And since LDS voters make up a full 34 percent of the district’s electorate, Hanauer said, that’s quite a population to lose ground with.

The survey found that conservatives in general, too, jumped ship from Pearce to Lewis.

“When you look at the fact that three in 10 conservatives sided with Lewis, that’s a pretty stunning number,” he said.


UPDATE: One other interesting point from the poll:

Immigration may not have been a motivating factor for most white voters, but Pearce is clearly not popular with Hispanics and that was a lynchpin to Pearce’s defeat. Lewis and Russell split the white vote, but Hispanics–13% of voters–broke against Pearce by a better than 3-to-1 margin.

2 responses to “Mormon Voters Recalled Pearce over ‘Character,’ Not Immigration”

  1. Anonymous says:

    Pearce lost because of low voter turnout in a district where there were no other races on the ballot. Roughly 20,000 voted last Tuesday vs. 31,000 in the 2010 general election. The anti-Pearce voters were more motivated to vote in the special election & the anti-Pearce coalition picked the right candidate, a “conservative” Mormon bishop but one who is opposed to immigration law enforcement. The election was essentially the same has having a Republican primary in which Democrats were allowed to vote _ the only other candidate, Olivia Cortez – Democrat, was hounded out of the race. It remains to be seen if Lewis will be able to win the actual Republican primary next year.

  2. patthemick says:

    The reason that he lost was the chamber of commerce wanting cheaper labor costs and supporting his opponent. I fear that we have more to fear from greed than hispanics. I’m sick of being betrayed by the darn rich guys.