Protesters Oppose Muslim Prayer in Public Schools

Tess Kalinowski, Parent Central, July 25, 2011

They waved signs that warned of “creeping jihad” and proclaimed “Islam must be reformed or banned.”

They chanted–“No Islam in our schools”; “No Mohamed in our schools”; “No Sharia law in our country.”

About 100 protesters, many from groups such as the Jewish Defense League, the Christian Heritage Party and Canadian Hindu Advocacy, came to the Toronto District School Board Monday evening to protest its approval of formal Friday prayer services for Muslim students at Valley Park Middle School.

Standing at the back of the crowds, far from the megaphone-wielding speakers, York University students Mariam Hamaoui and Sarah Zubaira had their own signs espousing their right to pray in school.

They came to thank the school board for providing a place for the Valley Park students to pray. Previously those students had left their school to attend prayers at a nearby mosque on Fridays.

Bringing an imam into the school was a means of preventing some of the approximately 300 Muslim students from failing to return to classes after those prayers, said school board director Chris Spence. It also meant they don’t have to cross a busy street.

Valley Park has been holding the prayers in the cafeteria for three years and there have been no complaints within the school community of about 1,200, he said.

Hamaoui, 18, said she had to go to the basement to pray when she attended Etobicoke Collegiate Institute because “there was no other place.”

“I think people should be open minded. I don’t see the problem to go pray. Praying is helping everybody,” she told reporters and the protesters who aggressively confronted her.

“Universities let anybody pray. I don’t see the problem with having middle schools,” she told one woman.

To a man who told her that prayer belonged at home, she said, “Is our school not a second home?”

“It’s our constitutional right,” said Zubaira, who wore a hijab for the first time on Monday.

Speaking to reporters inside the board office, Spence said schools have an obligation to religious accommodation.

“It’s not a matter of if we should be doing it–it’s how,” he said.

But, “accommodation is fluid. It’s not written in stone,” said Spence, who added the board is feeling its way on the difficult issue.

Outside on the board steps, Toronto grandmother Frances Flynt said she came to the protest to “oppose having a mosque in a school.”

She said her grandchildren are only permitted to sing secular songs like Jingle Bells at Christmas. “They’re not allowed to sing hymns in school,” she said.

Artist and atheist Ryan Browne came alone to the protest.

“I felt so strongly about it I decided I’d come down and do something about it,” he said, adding that he fears “our public institutions can be apprehended by certain interest groups.

“I work for the TDSB, I try to teach in an environment of equity. I just find this kind of rhetoric intolerant,” said Omar Qayum, a Muslim math teacher at Agincourt Collegiate.

For the past five years, he says, he’s been taking time on Fridays to pray with his students and there have been no problems.

“We have a Catholic school system. It is publicly funded. My tax dollars go to Catholic schools. I don’t have a problem so long as other religious groups have that same right but that’s not the case . . . When they talk about gender segregation, we have Catholic schools that are all girls and all boys. It’s just that Muslims are an easy target. We are a minority. Islamophobia is an industry these days,” said Qayum.


Share This

We welcome comments that add information or perspective, and we encourage polite debate. If you log in with a social media account, your comment should appear immediately. If you prefer to remain anonymous, you may comment as a guest, using a name and an e-mail address of convenience. Your comment will be moderated.

4 Responses to “Protesters Oppose Muslim Prayer in Public Schools” Subscribe

  1. Anonymous July 26, 2011 at 5:40 pm #

    It’s entertaining to see the “no school prayer” crowd confronted with Islam.

  2. olewhitelady July 26, 2011 at 5:53 pm #

    But isn’t it against Canadian law to hold religious services in public schools? If so, of course, such a law was meant only for Christians! Besides, according to the liberals, anything non-whites do is not blameworthy.

    I never hear anything about AMERICAN Jews and atheists protesting against anything Moslem, when, by supporting Islam, they’re sowing the very seeds that will destroy free expression of Judaism and atheism. The left so hates Christianity that it will side with anyone deemed to be in opposition to it.

  3. jewamongyou July 26, 2011 at 6:20 pm #

    In the 19th century, some folks got together and created “Reform Judaism”, which basically redefined Judaism as a social club and removed it from most of its past. Why can’t somebody invent a “Reform Islam” that doesn’t include all the bad stuff? They could even rewrite the Quran.

  4. olewhitelady July 27, 2011 at 7:22 am #


    First, let me say that when I stated that I never hear anything about American Jews protesting Islam, I meant in the MSM. I’ve certainly read criticism on the net and have personally known Jews who condemned the anti-Jewish words and actions of Moslems.

    Second, your remark about secular Jews reminds me of the kind of Christian that Anders Breivik appears to be–someone who thinks of religion only in an ethnocultural manner.

    As for Moslems who don’t go along lock-step with the Koran, I think that includes many individuals. They simply ignore the violent pronouncements or “reinterpret” them. Years ago, I worked with a Moslem woman from the island of Mauritius, off the east coast of Africa. She was of Indian descent and was married to an atheist Italian-American and was raising her children to be Moslem. She had worked in Britain, spoke perfect English, and was very Westernized. Now, I think of people like her as “bad” Moslems because they ignore the dictates of Islam.