Posted on August 12, 2010

With New Immigration Law and Arizona’s Slow Economy, Laborers See Work Drying Up

Daniel González, Arizona Republic, August 9, 2010

Just a few years ago, when the economy was booming, the area around the Home Depot on Thomas Road and 36th Street in east Phoenix was packed with a couple of hundred men congregating on sidewalks and street corners soliciting work as day laborers.

Day laborers, mostly undocumented Mexican immigrants, also proliferated in other areas around the Valley, places like Avenida del Yaqui in Guadalupe, 43rd Avenue and Camelback Road in west Phoenix and Saguaro Boulevard in Fountain Hills.

But drive by any of those locations now, and only a handful of day laborers are left. And no longer do they rush up to vehicles en masse, waving their hands in a desperate bid to get hired. Now, they are more likely to keep a lower profile, leaning against a tree or sitting on a milk crate.

There are several reasons for the change. Arizona’s slumping economy has dried up the demand for day laborers, who typically are hired for yard cleaning, moving, tree cutting, construction and other jobs. Many have left Arizona to look for work in other states, or they have given up and returned to Mexico.

And the state’s crackdown on illegal immigration also is taking a toll, including parts of Arizona’s tough new immigration law that took effect July 29.


State Rep. John Kavanagh, R-Fountain Hills, who sponsored the House version of Senate Bill 1070, said one of the law’s intentions was to prevent the “highly disruptive situation that occurred at Pruitt’s.”

In December 2007, day laborers congregating in front of Pruitt’s furniture store and other businesses on Thomas Road near the Home Depot ignited a dispute that dragged on for two months and propelled Arizona’s battle over illegal immigration into the national spotlight. The furniture store became a flashpoint in the illegal-immigration debate after it hired off-duty sheriff’s deputies to chase away day laborers from its parking lot, leading to demonstrations and counterdemonstrations.

Kavanagh said the law is also aimed at cracking down on the hiring of illegal immigrants because most day laborers tend to be undocumented people who work for cash and therefore don’t pay income taxes. The people who hire them also skip out on worker’s compensation payments, he said.


But law-enforcement officials say the law is clear. Police can’t arrest day laborers just for soliciting work.

“The key consideration is they have to be impeding traffic. It is legal for them to solicit work,” said Sgt. Tommy Thompson, a spokesman for the Phoenix Police Department.


Many of the day laborers interviewed for this story said they previously worked for construction or landscaping companies. They resorted to day-labor work after they lost their jobs, some because of the economy, others after a state law took effect in January 2008 that sanctions employers caught knowingly hiring illegal immigrants and requires them to run Social Security numbers of new employees though a federal electronic worker-verification system.

Aguilar, the day laborer in front of the Home Depot in east Phoenix, said a few years ago he sometimes got hired twice in the same day, once early in the morning and then again in the afternoon. Now, he said, he’s lucky if he gets hired twice in one week.