Migrant Smuggling Still Rampant Despite Promised Crackdown

The United States is urging Mexico to put an end to trafficking, but government efforts to stem the flow are hampered by corruption and have consistently come up short.

ALTAR, Sonora—A year after a spectacular police swoop on migrant trafficking in this town on the U.S. border, the plaza bustles with smugglers closing deals.

The United States has urged Mexico to crack down harder, warning that terrorists could tap into the flourishing industry. But Mexico says it can do little at the northern border because although abetting illegal crossings for a fee is a crime, there’s no law to stop would-be migrants gathering near the frontier.

Instead, it appears to have focused on stopping the flow of U.S.-bound migrants from South and Central America at its southern border. In March, police carried out a nationwide sweep against one of the largest migrant-trafficking rings ever uncovered in Mexico.

It netted 42 current and former government employees in 12 of the country’s 31 states who allegedly smuggled Cubans, Uruguayans, Brazilians, Asians and Central Americans across the nation’s southern border. Those arrested included agents and former agents of the National Migration Institute who allegedly helped foreigners sneak into the United States.

Authorities said corrupt officials illegally freed captured migrants, falsified documents to get them through Mexico, and guaranteed them safe passage into the United States.

The raid at Altar, a town of 7,000 lying 60 miles (100 kilometers) south of Arizona, caught 27 suspects and rounded up about 60 Central Americans for deportation. Hundreds of Mexican migrants were encouraged to return home, and Interior Secretary Santiago Creel promised more raids would follow.

Yet Altar remains the busiest crossing point along the northern border, and trafficking apparently goes on undisturbed. Boarding houses are almost always full, and many farmers have abandoned their fields and opened restaurants and shops that cater to the transient population.

Last year’s arrests were “a complete spectacle,” said Francisco García, Altar’s mayor at the time. “But as far as I’m concerned, they didn’t have any effect because here things remain the same.” García said the raids were just a symbolic response to U.S. pressure, coming two weeks after 19 migrants died of heat and asphyxiation while being smuggled from the border to Houston in a tractor-trailer.

Visiting Mexico in February, U.S. Homeland Security Secretary Tom Ridge asked the government to step up patrols along Mexico’s side of the border, saying it would help head off terrorism. In an agreement signed at the time, the government agreed to crack down on migrant smugglers.

But breaking up the smuggling rings has proven difficult.

The Interior Secretariat estimates that as many as 100 smuggling gangs operate across the nation, charging up to US1,800 per migrant.

José Luis Santiago Vasconcelos, chief prosecutor in charge of organized crime investigations, said corrupt officials are one of the main roadblocks.

They “stain our country’s reputation and as a result our efforts seem to evaporate,” Vasconcelos said. “Everyone is making a great effort to stop this type of activity.” Last year, Congressman Tarcisio Navarrete, a member of the ruling National Action Party (PAN), proposed stiffer jail sentences and fines, and broader police powers to investigate suspected smuggling operations. Currently police can only act on a citizen’s complaint.

But Navarrete’s term ended in November and his bill has been abandoned.

Critics say the solution lies in job creation, not in tougher policing or in the Paisano program set up in 1989 to help returning migrants.

“For the Mexican government, it is easy to create a program to welcome migrants coming home,” said García, the ex-mayor. “But they don’t do anything to help them before they become migrants.” Luis Sánchez, a 30-year-old farmer from southern Oaxaca state, said he has crossed illegally into the United States four times.

“We always cross through Altar because here no one bothers you,” Sánchez said. “In the last four years, I’ve always crossed in my first attempt because I’m well prepared. I take salt pills and plenty of water.”