Man Caught Viciously Beating Another Guy over a Subway Seat (VIDEO)

New York Post, June 13, 2011

{snip}

This time, straphangers were treated to a fight between two riders who got into it over a subway seat.

The melee, caught on video and posted to YouTube on Sunday, shows a man relentlessly wailing on another guy.

While the man punches the cowering guy over and over, another man and woman tried to put an end to it.

{snip}

Topics:

Share This

We welcome comments that add information or perspective, and we encourage polite debate. If you log in with a social media account, your comment should appear immediately. If you prefer to remain anonymous, you may comment as a guest, using a name and an e-mail address of convenience. Your comment will be moderated.
  • Casper, so White!

    We watch this video of REAL AMERICA on June 14, 2011, the 150th anniversary of Nathan Bedford Forrest’s enlistment as a private in service of the South.

    He was right, and Whites are using White-invented technology every day to prove that he was right.

    All praises and devotion to our great hero, Nathan Bedford Forrest!

  • Rudolph

    Would someone please at least knock the glasses off that criminal? Is that man castrated? Wow, I can’t wait until someone tries to pull that around me.

  • Stunned

    The sooner the better; anybody have a better idea?

  • AWG (AVERAGE WHITE GUY)

    The Rosa Parks syndrome has claimed an other victim in New York.

    Credit the racist hate delivered daily by the media and entertainment industry. Blacks in America have come to believe that every White person deserves a beating; particularly on public transit systems and school buses.

    This is why we had Jim Crow laws. It was not to discriminate against people with dark skin tone. Rather, Jim Crow laws were designed to protect White people from being attacked by black racists.

  • Stunned

    One comment on the CBS New York Story was as follows: “My wife and I were on the train when this incident happened. It actually started when the white guy (the black guys lover) started hitting him and then on the platform they started hugging and kissing, both inchoherent. We entered the subway car one down because we were not liking how they acted. When they got on train they started fighting, not sure how all this got into such racial comments above, it was not the case, guess I see how media gets the fact mixed up.” A gay interracial lovers’ spat?

  • myhouse

    One of b hussein obama’s plots is to force whites to use public transportation, (high gas prices, trying to force us to buy costly electric cars, government takeover of car manufacturers), just for this reason.

  • Anonymous

    I am almost tempted to call this incident fake, watching how slowly the punches are being delivered. But on closer examination (good copy of the video by the way), the people involved are just weak. The victim appears to be a rather young man and the attacker looks rather old and feeble. Nobody involved seems to know the least bit about fighting (here’s a clue….if you know nothing about fighting, don’t get involved….you are likely to die….no joke…..it looks silly until someone pulls a knife)

  • Anonymous

    Where’s Bernhard Goetz when you need him?

  • Anonymous

    I’m sorry but that guy deserved to have the daylights beaten out of him. Any white man that needs a woman to defend him needs to get a bloody nose and some good bruises.

    Are there any white men left? If the races were reverse, the two ‘saviors’ would have been beating the offender!

  • Anonymous

    I would have just reached over and put a thumb squeeze on his eyeball…

  • American Cowboy

    Fight Back! No one likes getting punched in the face, not even crazy blacks. The more you punch the attacker the less he is going to punch you. If you hurt him he will look to end the attack much sooner.

    You don’t have to be Rocky just get a few good ones in and the punk won’t enjoy his game anymore. Plus your feel better about yourself the next day.

  • WASP

    I’ll be totally honest. You white “men” make me ill when you don’t fight back. Have you all been neutered?

    Watch this vid.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BODWUohtXHo

    A room full of white “men” and they do nothing as “bro-zilla” beats the small guy senseless. Mexicans would have beaten bro-zilla half to death to defend the much smaller man.

    I have little hope for our race.

  • highduke

    Blacks do provoke but rarely attack a another person of comparable build if the person shows no fear. They bet on the ‘thug’ image while knowing that the image itself depends on having a gun to back it up and since most are unarmed, all it takes is a confident response to shenanigans like playing chicken on the sidewalk and they wont fight, they walk away even with the N-WORD ringing in their ears.

  • Anonymous

    Use your keys, aim for his eyes or his throat. You bystanders had plenty of time to stop and think about it, a little self-defense goes a long way.

  • Edmundo

    “This time, straphangers were treated to a fight between two riders who got into it over a subway seat.”

    This is fight??

    I guess when a black pounds on a white it’s a ‘fight’, implying two willing and consenting combatants.

    If it is a white wailing on a black it’s aggravated assault, possibly attempted murder, and definitely a ‘hate crime’.

    I have also noticed firsthand, while growing-up, how blacks love to cherry-pick their battles. They treat youngsters, and the feeble looking the worst.

  • Frank Keliher

    This reminds me of a similar incident in the Washington, D.C. Metro subway around 8 years ago that I read about in the newspaper and then followed up by attending the trial several weeks later.

    The newspape report indicated that one man politely asked another for permission to sit in a vacant seat next to him on a crowded train during the morning rush hour near the Foggy Bottom station. The first man asked twice and the other didn’t respond so the first man, interpreting silence as assent, took the seat.

    That was a big mistake, for the seated man proceeded to beat the other so badly that he had to be administered oxygen and taken from the station on a gurney by a rescue squad.

    The assailnt was apprehended and arrested and I was interested in attending his trial because (1) I passed the Foggy Bottom station every day, and (2) more immportantly, the newspaper accounts did not mention the races involved and my suspicions needed confirmation.

    I could see at the trial that the assailnt was black, but the victim did not appear, so I had to ask the arresting officer, who was black, was the victim white? “Yes,” he responded with a proud smile. No apology, no shame, just a beaming grin.

    The perp turned out to be an enormous, heavily muscled black with many arrests and convictions on his record. He had been out of jail only a short time when he did the assault. The judge in the case gave him a heavy sentence, remarked “this is why I don’t look anyone in the eye or speak to anyone when I ride the subway,” and both bailiffs who escorted the convict out of the courtroom (in other cases only one bailiff was necessary) wore rubber gloves.

    The only reason there are not more incidents like this is that the whites submit, make way for blacks, and do not fight back. Note in the video that the two whites who came to help didn’t attack the black attacker, but tried only to restrain him.

    Come to think of it, a worse incident occurred at the Pentagon Metro station during the noon, lunchtime rush when the subway car was filled with soldiers and airmen. An absolutely gorgeous blonde white woman Air Force Colonol sat down next to me in the double seat facing the door of the train. A newspaper was left on the seat she occupied so she picked it up and held it in her hand as she spoke to a companion who was standing. All of a sudden WHACK!! You could hear the noise all over the car. A black man around 40 years old, wearing a sweat suit, sitting facting the front of the car, at a right angle to the Colonol, had slapped the paper out of her hand, and snarled, “if you were MY woman.” and “if you had any class” etc.

    The only response this got from the many “white warriors” in the crowded car was a few dirty looks.

    My experience is that whites are completely cowed by blacks. And any white who dares to resist must fear a Judge and jury even more than any black he might face.

  • Anonymous

    That guy deserved to get beaten. What a spineless sack of puke. fight BACK!!!

  • Disgusted

    Notice that one of the people trying to stop the fight was a non-White woman?

    Except fior one White man, all the Whites were standing around watching. We Whites have become a sad lot.

  • Karl Ketzer

    White guy number one cowering like a little sissy while white guy number two was trying to talk the black out of his misbehavior.

    Absolutely contemptible.

    Where’s Epic Beard Man when you need him?

    http://www.break.com/fights/epic-beard-man-bus-fight.html

  • Anonymous

    Why is it that whenever minorities are fighting or involved in a brawl(I know this incident wasnt a brawl) they use the word melee? It seems like the word melee is used to make it seem like not a big deal or something.

  • Ed

    I see these videos all the time of whites either taking or observing the beatings. I do not know these people. I would not behave like an animal but I would have surely ended that situation after ONE warning. Why didn’t the white mediator throw one well placed punch when he had the chance. I think whites that now reside in cities are (hopefully) a different breed.

  • Chicagoan

    Blacks have degraded public transportation for years. Making noise on purpose, throwing garbage around, mugging people, things like in the video, the list goes on. They sure know how to ruin all public life.

  • Anonymous

    That fat black guy looks to be middle aged. So much for the “good” older blacks, eh? Yep, Whites take it and do not help each other. Blacks know this! They sense fear and when Whites had control before desegregation, the blacks feared the Whites. They did not come into our neighborhoods or schools.

    So what happened to Whites? It can’t just be brainwashing, can it? I know there are many Whites who bought into the guilt trip and think we, Whites, deserve what we get from blacks. Is it because of our enemy instituting hate crime laws against Whites only? Getting fired from their jobs? Going to jail even if they are the victim and losing their job and all their resources? Getting sued? Believing the media, movies and constant propaganda against us? Being called a racist, nazi, hatemonger, etc? Demonized over and again if you defend your own race as other races are all allowed to do?

    WHY did we ALLOW all this to take place? Are we so weak and intimidated that we will settle and lose our very lives, our nation and our children to the hordes who demand our heads?

    Something has to give. If we do not find our warrior spirit and soon, then all is lost forever and ever. There will be no rebound.

  • Wayne Engle

    First of all, apparently no one — except other black thugs, that is — carries heat when they go downtown in New York. If they did, and they were in that subway car, I’ll wager that thug would be dead now. Second, how much brain power does it take for those people trying to break up the fight to think, “Maybe if I pick up something hard and hit this perp over the head with it, his own pain will cause him to stop assaulting this wimp who can’t seem to do anything but cover up and wait for the beating to stop.”

    Wonder if anyone thought to call the police on their cell phone. The reporter apparently didn’t even bother to check on that; he was having so much fun describing how another White guy got beat to crap.

  • Anonymous

    I was once berated by an angry black male for not taking an open seat on the subway next to a black female. I was looking around for an open seat and chose to sit alone where both seats were vacant. The lunatic said “I saw what you were doing!” after I looked around and chose to sit on the vacant bench.

    Damned if you do, damned if you don’t when dealing with blacks. Many, who have nothing better to do, seem to ride the trains all day and all night.

  • Anonymous

    Whites have to fear legal consequences and have the judicial deck stacked against them. Still he should have fought back. Do whatever you can to defend yourself from these animals.

  • Anonymous

    This is more of that “Hope and Change” Obama promised.

  • AWG (AVERAGE WHITE GUY)

    Recall the Bernhard Goetz was sued for $50 million after he defended himself. Recall, also, the White pharmcist who was sentenced to life in prison for shooting a black intruder.

    White people are by nature intelligent and civil.

    My guess is this guy was shocked and in pain; ignorant of the jungle mentality and taken by surprise.

    The attacker may well have been on drugs and was insensitive to pain.

    Whatever the case, had this been a black male being beaten by a White man, it would have been national news as proof that White folks are racist.

  • Lex Concord

    From what I can see, the reason the black’s punches are weak is that he is middle aged and probably ran out of wind pretty quick. He may have been drunk as well..who knows? And no, this isn’t a fight, it’s a beating, weak though it is.

    I can’t really tell how many people of what color are in the vicinity of this incident. I know that whites are VERY reluctant to intervene on behalf of other whites when there are other blacks around because they believe that more blacks will pile on, but more whites probably won’t. I think in most cases that is correct, although it gives me no pleasure to say so.

    The Epic Beard Man video is interesting because the black assailant messed up big time. Although Beard Man is older, he is stout, and clearly not afraid. Blackbully felt he had the home court advantage. Beard Man had some experience, and destroyed him in short order. The funny part is that blackbully just can’t believe it happened. The black passengers are amazed too. It was probably a unique occurrence for them.

  • fred

    This is just one more in a long line of videos showing blacks attacking people of other races in restaurants and public transportation. As some have already mentioned, this was the real reason for segregating lunch counters and seating blacks at the back of the bus.

  • Cousin Charlie from TN

    I have never in 5+ years responded to or attacked a fellow Amrener due to a post I found stupid.

    Until now!

    “6 — myhouse wrote at 5:35 PM on June 14:

    One of b hussein obama’s plots is to force whites to use public transportation, (high gas prices, trying to force us to buy costly electric cars, government takeover of car manufacturers), just for this reason.”

    You “myhouse” are an idiot; I hope you never darken my screen again.

    The NYC public transit system was invented & evolved eons before you or Obama were born. By and for the residents thereto (overwhelmingly white back then). Before “everyone” owned cars. Before leftism was the norm. So the apples & oranges deal is pretty obvious. That system was an ingenious way to get masses of people to & from efficiently in the largest city in the world.

    Also, please type into the computer like an educated mature person, not a 6-year old.

    Otherwise, have a nice day!

  • Anonymous

    5 — Stunned wrote at 5:32 PM on June 14:

    One comment on the CBS New York Story was as follows: “My wife and I were on the train when this incident happened. It actually started when the white guy (the black guys lover) started hitting him and then on the platform they started hugging and kissing, both inchoherent. We entered the subway car one down because we were not liking how they acted. When they got on train they started fighting, not sure how all this got into such racial comments above, it was not the case, guess I see how media gets the fact mixed up.” A gay interracial lovers’ spat?

    ______________________________

    If that was the case then it makes more sense. The White guy was the “woman” in the relationship as he acted like one. Gays commit domestic violence all the time against their partner, more so than heteros. It isn’t publicized of course.

    Don’t feel sorry for the White “guy” now that he is involved in such a “relationship”.

  • olewhitelady

    #5 Stunned is almost certainly correct–these were gays having a catfight. That’s probably why only women were bothering to intervene.

    #20 mentioned that blacks often call their fights “brawls”. On cop shows, I usually hear the word “tussle”, as though all the mayhem is roll-and-tumble play between children!

  • Joe

    The behavior of the attacker is understood, even expected. But the lack of fight in the victim is discouraging. The attacker is not a strong fighter and a spirited defense would have broken him in seconds. Instead, this egalitarian tree hugging vegan just stood limp and took the beating.

  • George

    Blacks are why there is very little public transportation in this country.

  • MuayTyson

    #26 is correct it is a cost benefit analysis for Whites. Blacks can not control their impulses there for they do not take the extra few seconds to weigh the odds.

    I’m a big guy and I train in martial arts if I step in and help a victim I face criminal charges as well as civil charges. It doesn’t matter if the minority offender doesn’t have two nickels to rub together he/she will be supported by NAACP, ACLU, etc. Who will support me in the subsequent trials?

    Even to go to trail and be found innocent you need a lawyer they cost money and for God’s sake do not trust a public defender they will get you hanged.

    Sorry to say but for most whites it is better to walk away or give a report to the police when they finally show up. I wish it were not so but it is.

  • Old White Jim

    Some of you folks who are reading these words will get your chance to take a pummelling like the White guy in the video got, and more than likely you won’t have a pair of concerned but unskilled heroes making an ineffective attempt to save you.

    White people are going to have to learn how to fight back if they don’t want to be victims.

    You don’t have to become Jet Li or John Rambo to defend yourself against those unskilled bullies. Most of the clowns you see beating on people in videos similar to this one aren’t particularly tough. The only reason that they are winning is that their victims aren’t fighting back.

    When a thug is turning the rage loose on you, cowering and begging will only further bring out their worst. When you are being punched in the face and head you have absolutely nothing to lose by fighting back. Are you afraid you might make him mad? He, or she, is already mad or you wouldn’t be getting punched. You have nothing to lose.

    If you aren’t in shape, then work on getting in shape. Do some push ups or lift some weights. Go to a boxing or martial arts gym if you can afford it and have the time, or order a heavy bag and some “How To” CD’s from Ringside if you don’t. There are simple tricks you can learn that will make your bully wish that he’d picked a different cracker to mess with.

    Don’t be a shivering puppy. Show your teeth and use them if you must. When Whites quit being easy targets we will quit being targets.

  • Peejay in Frisco

    Fighting back works only if you prepare for it.Everyone should stay in shape,and practice some fighting techniques. And make sure that when you do fight back, it is after the assaliant has taken some offensive physical action against you, this way what you did was self defense.

  • Anonymous

    31 — Cousin Charlie from TN wrote at 6:23 AM on June 15:

    I have never in 5+ years responded to or attacked a fellow Amrener due to a post I found stupid.

    Until now!

    “6 — myhouse wrote at 5:35 PM on June 14:

    One of b hussein obama’s plots is to force whites to use public transportation, (high gas prices, trying to force us to buy costly electric cars, government takeover of car manufacturers), just for this reason.”

    You “myhouse” are an idiot; I hope you never darken my screen again.

    The NYC public transit system was invented & evolved eons before you or Obama were born. By and for the residents thereto (overwhelmingly white back then). Before “everyone” owned cars. Before leftism was the norm. So the apples & oranges deal is pretty obvious. That system was an ingenious way to get masses of people to & from efficiently in the largest city in the world.

    Also, please type into the computer like an educated mature person, not a 6-year old.

    Otherwise, have a nice day!

    ————————————————

    Me thinks you have not understood ONE word that the poster you are “calling out” as an “idiot” has said. We all know who and why public transportation was created.

    That isn’t the point the poster was making. Maybe if you reread his post, you might get his drift? I can barely afford my 12 year old car and the gas that goes into it and thanks to our government and their policies, we will soon be on that bus with blacks. Maybe you don’t consider that Whites are losing their livelihoods (through AA) and many of us older folks are trying to live on our shrinking SSA checks after working for 40 years.

  • S & GS

    5 — Stunned wrote at 5:32 PM on June 14:

    One comment on the CBS New York Story was as follows: “My wife and I were on the train when this incident happened. It actually started when the white guy (the black guys lover) started hitting him and then on the platform they started hugging and kissing, both inchoherent. We entered the subway car one down because we were not liking how they acted. When they got on train they started fighting, not sure how all this got into such racial comments above, it was not the case, guess I see how media gets the fact mixed up.” A gay interracial lovers’ spat?

    I saw that comment too and I believe it was just some smart aleck pinkifying the thread.

  • S & GS

    5 — Stunned wrote at 5:32 PM on June 14:

    One comment on the CBS New York Story was as follows: “My wife and I were on the train when this incident happened. It actually started when the white guy (the black guys lover) started hitting him and then on the platform they started hugging and kissing, both inchoherent. We entered the subway car one down because we were not liking how they acted. When they got on train they started fighting, not sure how all this got into such racial comments above, it was not the case, guess I see how media gets the fact mixed up.” A gay interracial lovers’ spat?

    I saw that comment too and I believe it was just some smart aleck pinkifying the thread.

  • S & GS

    I see a lot of macho comments on this thread that if the poster was there all would be taken care of-brutally and quickly. Keep in mind that this is the NYC Subway, not exactly a white homeland these days. It is Afro territory. Many of the whites still there are left wing fools who you can’t count on and as some have alluded to above when whitey acts it is a hate crime. Finally, many whites may not be as physically and pugilistically adept. Rather than blame the white victim blame the savage times we are FORCED to live in (while agreeing that they should try to improve their skills and street smarts).

  • S & GS

    I see a lot of macho comments on this thread that if the poster was there all would be taken care of-brutally and quickly. Keep in mind that this is the NYC Subway, not exactly a white homeland these days. It is Afro territory. Many of the whites still there are left wing fools who you can’t count on and as some have alluded to above when whitey acts it is a hate crime. Finally, many whites may not be as physically and pugilistically adept. Rather than blame the white victim blame the savage times we are FORCED to live in (while agreeing that they should try to improve their skills and street smarts).

  • fred

    #5 — Stunned

    I wouldn’t be so quick to believe this was a “gay interracial lovers’ spat” just because a single anonymous comment on the CBS New York website claims to have seen them “hugging and kissing”. That comment also complained about people recognizing the race of the participants. In other words, it’s possible the commenter was lying to cover up the racial angle.

  • Question Diversity

    37 Old White Jim:

    Along with that, my strategy is to play if not totally certifiably crazy, then at the very least noticeably off the level and mentally unpredictable. I have mastered a believable dog growl and cat hiss.

  • white is right, black is whack

    Typical of fellow white men. The only white men that have any guts to stand up to black thugs and black bigots are older white men. The young white are too busy trying to get them to like them and be “hip” and “tolerant.” How’s that working, young white men? I will not tolerate this. A black thug tries this to me or anyone around them–even if they aren’t white–I will pound them into the pavement. White men, of all ages, stay fit, exercise, don’t back down to these anti-white bigots, buy some unregistered firearms, learn self-defense moves, carry mace on you (especially white females!) and be prepared. I hate violence and pre-emptive attacks, but we need to be ready to defend ourselves.

  • NYC Resident

    I’ve got news for some posters here who claim that if they were the White guy, they would have “done this” and they would have “done that”. No you wouldn’t. That’s just bravado. You wouldn’t have done anything either. Whites are scared to death of Blacks both physically and psychologically, and also afraid of being called racist if they were to fight back. I live in this city, and I’ve NEVER seen a White fight back against a Black in any effective way whatsoever, and I’ve seen many an altercation. I’ve had the same psychological paralysis. It stems from a feeling – and a legitimate one – that if you do “fight back” in any way, you will all alone in your endeavor. No one will assist you if you show some manhood. I’ve seen Whites do nothing but back down. I’ve never seen a White man or woman in this city confront a loud and rude Black. I’ve never seen a White kid stand up to a Black kid. It is extremely disheartening. A very wise man who educated me on this situation said that before Whites can do anything, they’re going to have to experience extreme deprivation and suffering. In other words, it’s going to have to get a lot worse, before it gets better, if indeed it ever will.

  • Another NYC Resident

    NYC Resident wrote:

    I’ve got news for some posters who claim that if they were the White guy, they would have “done this” and they would have “done that”. No you wouldn’t! That’s just bravado. You wouldn’t have done anything either.

    Whites are scared to death of Blacks, both physically and psychologically, and are also afraid of being called racist.

    I live in this city, and I’ve NEVER seen a White fight back against a Black in any way whatsoever,… if you do “fight back” in any way, you will all alone in your endeavor. No one will assist you. I’ve seen Whites do nothing but back down.

    I’ve never seen a White man or woman in this city confront a loud and rude Black. I’ve never seen a White kid stand up to a Black kid.

    ____________________

    All very true, and well put! As another NYC resident I can confirm his observations. Even in the workplace, a white will never stand up for another white. There’s always the fear of the dreaded word, “racist”. Any white would be fearful and ASHAMED to show solidarity with another white. Most of them would go out of their way to show favor to the other side. With a lifetime of brainwashing, that’s what we have come to!

  • Ed Ruffin

    I am a pretty physical guy, but i must admit fear of race prosecution has kept me from straightening out a number of blacks i wanted to lay out.Most folks feel you can’t harm one hair on their bristly heads and be treated fairly.Most also fear a mob beatdown by other blacks with no dog in the fight. When our culture starts encouraging and rewarding vigilantism you will see some real backbone from whites.

  • WHC

    When it comes to street fights with blacks, there are no rules. If you get into a fight with one black, other blacks in the vicinity will join their “brother” against a white, even if they have never met the black fighter. Whites maintain an antiquated notion of a “fair fight” between two relatively equal combatants. On the other hand blacks operate very much with a “pack” mentality. The only way to deal with a pack is with a firearm. During World War II, many of our troops sported a tattoo that stated “Death Before Dishonor.” That’s the way whites used to believe. It’s way past time to return to that way of thinking.

  • Viking77

    I have to say that NYC resident does make an interesting point, but I can tell you that I have seen whites stand up to blacks. Of course I will admit many of them were bikers or ex cons. It’s true that being labeled a racist is something many whites don’t want to deal with, but often times many whites have soft upbringings compared to blacks from the ghetto. Many whites can’t handle dealing with people who behave as if they have nothing to lose!(Many don’t)